Skip to content

Proper potluck etiquette

Proper potluck etiquette

My wife and I have different ideas on what to take to a potluck. Obi Wan and Darth Vader different. Sherlock Holmes and Jim Moriarty different.

For example, Obi Wan would take homemade potato salad; Darth Vader would bring a box of Oreos with three cookies missing. Sherlock would take goat cheese spinach artichoke dip; Moriarty would bring chips that would in no way go with goat cheese, spinach, or artichokes, and may be explosive.

“There’s a potluck at the Toddler’s school tonight,” my wife said. After nearly 16 years of marriage she’s gotten the ‘Don’t tell Jason anything until the last minute or he’ll find a way to back out’ thing down pat. “We need to take something.”

Panic didn’t set in. Cooking something awesome for people I don’t know is a challenge I’m always up for. If I’d been alive during WW I think I could have ended hostilities on July 29, 1914 with a Crock-Pot of Philly cheesesteak dip and a big bowl of homemade pita chips.

“OK,” I said, formulating a shopping list in my head. Trimmed strip loin, provolone cheese, Poblano peppers, beer. Lots of beer. You know, to keep my sanity. Mushrooms, onions … “When do we need to be there?”

“Five o’clock.”

Great. Cool. For the pitas, I’ll need flour, fresh garlic, olive oil…

“I’ll pick up some chips and Oreos,” she said and stopped my thoughts as surely as if she’d hit me with a frying pan.

“Chips?” Did I hear her correctly? “Chips are easy. Chips are … lazy.”

She shrugged. “So what? Everybody likes chips.”

I will admit it was the kind of argument that would probably stand up in a court of law.

“Let’s look at it this way,” I said, trying to make my failing point sound rational. “If there were 50 dishes at the potluck dinner, the probability of everyone bringing chips is … is … OK, so it’s only three percent, but still. It could happen.”

“I’ll get Doritos,” she said, leaving for the grocery store. “Everybody likes Doritos.”

There are sacred rules for a potluck.

• Don’t assume the main course and bring condiments. Ketchup doesn’t go with everything, or anything.

• A lot of people don’t like cold spaghetti. There. I said it.

• Raisins do NOT go in potato salad. What kind of world did you grow up in? I don’t want to know.

• Store-bought coleslaw is a travesty of nature.

• The same goes for cookies.

• Don’t bring anything in a bucket.

• Don’t complain about the drinks – the tea is always instant.

• Don’t be Darth Vader. It’s not cool to eat any of the food before you get there.

She brought home two bags of chips and a box of Oreos. I didn’t look to see if there was anything missing.

“Let’s go,” she said.

There’s a potluck at church on Sunday. Maybe we’ll bring an unopened box of Hamburger Helper.

Hey, look everybody, it’s the Offutts.

Jason’s newest novel, “Bad Day for a Road Trip,” is available at jasonoffutt.com.

Leave a Comment