Skip to content

A View from the Country: Immigration problems

A View from the Country: Immigration problems

At the end of August Rep. Sam Graves placed an article in the Forum discussing illegal immigration.

His article focused upon the terrible murder of a young lady in Iowa by an illegal farm worker. It is unfortunate that he chose to use this personal tragedy to make political points.

He did not note that illegal immigrants commit fewer crimes per capita than American citizens. It is an unhappy situation for anyone to be killed, but immigrants are less prone to doing so than citizens.

Still, it would be better to focus on some facts about illegal immigration than on one case. The Center for Immigration Studies has noted that “Nearly half of the 12 million plus aliens in the United States arrive legally with temporary non-immigration visas.”

The Department of Homeland Security did a survey of 1000 legal permanent residents, 30 percent of whom were previously illegal aliens. A third of these entered the U.S. on a temporary visa and simply overstayed their legal visit.

They come as tourists, students, on business. And this does not count visitors from Europe, Japan, Australia and New Zealand who do not need visas to visit America. Many also come and simply stay.

Still, It’s easy to get a visa. You apply at a U.S. consulate, fill out paperwork and wait for approval. A full 74 percent of the 5 million applicants in 2007 were approved. A great deal of them within countries plagued by authoritarian governments (80 percent of Chinese, 88 percent of Russians) while those applying from poor countries with bad economies and/or bad governments have similarly high approval rates.

In point of fact, America is an easy country to enter. And then to overstay your visa. The highly educated are especially adept at working the system with the help of American employers.

On top of visiter visas there is a system by which Green Cards can be granted in countries who do not have many immigrants in the United States. There is a lottery for the scarce Green Cards that allow you to stay and work legally.

Of 188 countries in the lottery, six countries account for 80 percent of the Green Card entries: Nigeria, Ukraine, Egypt, Morocco, Bangladesh, Ethiopia.

The fact is that there are many ways to get to America and many stay illegally. The solution of the Trump/Graves faction is to build a wall. It is true that Mexico accounts for a large percentage of illegal entrants but many come invited.

There is one estimate that over a quarter of a million illegals get into the country to work for American farmers and ranchers and others. Note that farmers can’t find citizens who will do the hard work. There must be some blind eyes towards these businesses.

A somewhat hidden fact is that the American birthrate is at its lowest in 30 years. Add to that the baby-boom generation is aging and you find an increasing need for workers. Historically, this need has been filled by immigrant.

Our immigration policies are enforced selectively if at all. The people and corporations that hire illegals are seldom prosecuted. If they are fined, they simply take that as part of doing business and go on as usual (anyone have their roofs repaired some years ago by migrant roofers employing illegals?)

Yet if families come across the border seeking asylum (this is legal), the government separates the children, doesn’t keep records of where their mothers are, puts them in concentration camps and washes their hands of the problem when media point to the inhumanity.

These folks are fleeing Central American countries taken over by gangs and thugs who rape and kill at will. Why doesn’t the American government attack this problem at its source with help for these countries?

What, besides exercising heavy handed and non-humanitarian approaches, has this government and its members of congress done to address these problems? A wall would hardly scratch the surface.

It’s time to rethink the whole immigrant policy of the United States, not select singular cases and generalize from them with simplistic solutions.

Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.

Leave a Comment