A View from the Country: Denuclearization, probably not

A View from the Country: Denuclearization, probably not
Foreign policy has taken center stage this last week and a half. It has been trade and peace that dominated the conversation.
Trade because President Trump has a thing about the balance of trade between major trading nations and the United States. Trade is a complex system and since World War II the international system has step-by-step lessened trade barriers between nations helping to create tremendous increases in international wealth.
It’s complex, but the reduction of tariff barriers has been a key part of this international prosperity. Now Trump is unilaterally increasing tariffs on goods that he claims costs American jobs.
But that means other nations can punish our trade goods by placing their tariffs (really an international tax) on our goods. Back and forth it could go creating harm to all sides. And it has undercut the most important alliance system in the democratic world.
The G-7 meeting in Canada, a meeting of the world’s major economies and basically America’s allies, was thrown into disarray because of the attitude of President Trump. The host Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, spoke for most when he simply said that Canada would not be pushed around.
Trump attacked Trudeau and embarrassed the G-7. Bullying was the primary method of diplomacy demonstrated by President Trump. But he wanted to look strong going into a summit with the world’s chief dictator, so he doubled down on attacking Canada, America’s chief trading partner, and England, America’s oldest partner.
He attacked Germany for sending so many cars, not knowing, I guess, that most of the German cars sold in America are assembled in America. Ah, those nasty facts.
Then on to the major foreign policy event, the summit with Kim Jong Un. You’ve read about the outcome, with various interpretations. Let’s talk about the pluses and minuses for the two leaders and their countries.
On the plus side for the United States, President Trump showed statesmanship by arranging a meeting that lowered the rhetoric between two nuclear nations and furthered the hope for denuclearization of the Korean peninsula.
A plus for Kim because he was turned overnight from a pariah in the world into an “equal” international figure.
China also won since it seems to have brokered the meeting and rewarded Kim with the dropping of international sanctions on North Korea. This is a significant step aiding the North since its economy is in the tubes.
The negatives were reflected in the ending statement from the meeting. It was all flowers and kisses, but no substance. Tall hats, no cattle. Kim said he’d denuclearize. But the North said the same in 1992, 1996, and 2005 and cheated on all three agreements. He gave no specifics.
Kim got all that he could hope for, including a statement by Trump that the joint military exercises with the South that had been the key to our South Asia strategy in keeping the North in line, were “provocative” and would cease. Kim could not ask for more. Again, he had to give nothing but rhetoric.
Quick high level meetings without much preparation are bound to have results that are basically PR. Substantive, detailed negotiations take time and thought. Both Kim and Trump will now trumpet their great successes with significant propaganda campaigns. Since Kim controls all aspects of communications in the North (for example, there is only one dial station on radios, tuned to the state’s propaganda).
One secondary result of the meeting deserves praise. Trump got a pledge from Kim to work for recovery of the remains of POWs from the Korean War (1950-53). There are 8,000 American soldiers unaccounted for, a continuing sore on America’s soul.
Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.
