Skip to content

My Word: Holding up a mirror

My Word: Holding up a mirror

A mirror isn’t always pleasant because of what stares back, but it can be an aid to truth.

An interesting political transformation occurred within the Democratic party from 1964 to the present. During this lengthy period, leadership has managed to convince a large part of the American electorate liberals alone are champions of civil rights. Conservatives, lefties insist, are incapable of the enlightenment that guides the left.

These assertions are disassociated with the history of the Democratic party with which the hard left aligns and why all Americans are obligated to know our history.

In 1860, Abraham Lincoln was the Republican candidate for the presidency; his main Democratic opponent was Stephen A. Douglas. Lincoln wanted an end to institutional slavery. Douglas didn’t care “..whether slavery was voted up or down…” as long as it was voted on by the people. Douglas favored “popular sovereignty” and was strongly supported by pro-slavery Southerners.

Upon election, Douglas received 12 electoral votes; Lincoln received 180 electoral votes, clearly indicating the country wanted change. The Republican party became the party of Lincoln. (source: various, but including Team of Rivals by Doris Kearns Goodwin)

Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation on Jan. 1, 1863, as an executive order. By liberating slaves within areas controlled by the Union army, Lincoln set the stage for the Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments, all of which were ratified via a complicated and acrimonious process.

The Thirteenth Amendment abolished all slavery and involuntary servitude and was signed by Lincoln Feb. 1, 1865. Every Republican in the House voted for it; 56 Democrats voted against it.

Andrew Johnson, a Democrat and unionist, became president following Lincoln’s assassination. Johnson was not a supporter of equal rights for freed blacks and opposed the Fourteenth Amendment, sweeping legislation that granted citizenship rights and equal protection under the law. The Fourteenth Amendment was opposed by congressional Democrats who were against equal rights for freed slaves, but the amendment became law when a majority of Republicans voted for it while a majority of Democrats voted against it.

The Fifteenth Amendment (1870) guaranteed the right to vote regardless of race. 144 Republicans in the House voted for it; 39 Dems and a handful of Republicans were opposed. The percentage was similar in the Senate. Republicans got the Amendment ratified despite Democratic resistance.

Ulysses S. Grant, a Republican, was elected president following Johnson’s lousy record of support for blacks struggling in the South. Grant did much for black rights via Reconstruction but was severely hindered by the rise of racist militant activism. Groups such as the KKK aligned with southern Democrats to resist laws and the newly amended Constitution. (one source: Grant by Ron Chernow)

Reconstruction failed to guarantee full citizenship for blacks in the South. White resistance to black equality was horrifically violent; in some ways, the Civil War continued for decades within the volatile region with political support not Republican.

Instead of fairness, blacks in the South got reprehensible Jim Crow laws which amounted to legalized segregation of schools, parks, transportation, restrooms and restaurants. Jim Crow laws were state mandated throughout the South (and elsewhere) from 1896 to 1965 and were supported by ubiquitous Democratic governors and legislatures.

America’s first fully progressive president, Woodrow Wilson, a southern Democrat, segregated federal workplaces in 1913, setting back racial growth for years.

Decades later, Brown v Board of Education finally ended segregation in schools via the Supreme Court ruling but not instantly. It took President Eisenhower, a Republican, using federal troops to integrate Central High School in Little Rock, Arkansas. in 1957 to get the message out. The Democratic governor, Orval Faubus, had forcefully resisted the federal order.

Gov. George Wallace, a Democrat and virulent racist and segregationist, tried similar tactics later at the University of Alabama and failed.

Civil rights efforts were resisted by Democrats during much of the turbulent civil rights age. The movement itself was accomplished far more by African Americans fed up with injustice than by white liberals who arrived late but saw burgeoning political opportunity within the black community. White liberals take way more credit for civil rights progress than is justified.

The important Civil Rights Act of 1964 was passed during the Lyndon Johnson administration with 82 percent approval by Republicans but only 69 percent of Democrats in the Senate; in the House, 80 percent of Republicans approved but only 63 percent of Democrats. (source: Wiki)

The aforementioned illustrates both the support of Republicans for equal rights for all and the historical weakness of Democrats’ claims. It seems likely shifting demographics gave rise to liberal sympathies in the last half century with an eye on political expediency. Social justice pioneers? Hardly.

Voters should be healthily skeptical of liberal claims regarding all things connected to civil rights progress. Liberal contention that conservatives resist equality is bogus and is itself prejudicial and divisive.

Larry W. Anderson is a retired educator, author and skeptic.

Leave a Comment