After Thanksgiving tax woes

Richard Fulton
Enjoy your Thanksgiving break but be prepared for post-thanksgiving tax bill politics. Don’t get too lost in Christmas preparations because what congress does to the tax bill, and potentially your health insurance, will affect your life directly and soon.
Although the House and the Senate are both controlled by Republicans, the two entities have come up with conflicting bills that they call “tax reform” but are both better described as tax realignment.
America’s tax laws are unduly complex. This is by design. And don’t expect whatever comes out of the present deliberations to be much simpler. In addition, while large issues of tax exemptions and who gets higher or lower tax bills dominates the arguments, there will still remain a jungle of tax exemptions and loopholes in these bills put there by special interests.
Congress is supposed to have eliminated the ability of members to pepper money bills with sweetheart exemptions for special interests or their home districts, still whatever bill that comes out of congress labeled “tax reform” already has many sneaky provisions to help particular economic or geographic groups included.
The two houses have passed their own specific bills, but both champion the old chestnut of “trickle down” economics. You hear the arguments; give big business and the wealthy tax breaks and they will create jobs and increase pay with all that extra money.
I noted earlier that even though big corporations right now have three or four trillion dollars of money in accounts overseas, they have not used that extra cash to create jobs or certainly not to increase wages. Will tax reform be different?
Here are some things to look for in the two bills before us. First of all, what will the new tax brackets look like? The House reduces the bracket number to four, the Senate to seven. The results will affect how much you pay.
Corporate tax rates will plummet. But there are remaining more holes in the tax laws to help keep corporate taxes even lower than the stated percentage (we noted last week that over half the Fortune Five Hundred paid no taxes in recent years even with the current higher tax rates).
There is now something called the “alternate minimum tax” to supposedly ensure that nobody gets away with paying zero taxes regardless of deductions. Both bills eliminate this safeguard, thus aiding the rich who could not avoid at least this smaller tax.
The Senate and House bills do away with state and local income and sales tax deductions. The Senate eliminates all property tax interest deductions if you itemize; the House allows for deductions up to $10,000.
Standard deductions would double under both bills though personal exemptions would be eliminated. Watch to see which deductions are eliminated.
You will hear multiple arguments for and against the provisions of both houses. Neutral evaluators tend to say that the rich will benefit much more than the middle class, however.
One thing thrust into the House bill is the elimination of the Affordable Health Care Act mandate that all Americans have health insurance. This is yet another backdoor means some Republicans want to use to kill the Act. What this has to do with tax reform is beyond me.
Some middle class benefits expire by 2023 while the corporate tax breaks are permanent. A sneaky way to limit the cost of the reforms while keeping the rich happy.
Well, this is just a taste of what the congress is trying to do with tax “reform.” Keep an eye on what comes out of the negotiations between the two houses.
Finally, my hope this week is that you have as many things to be thankful for as do I.
Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.
