Senior Center funding issue doesn’t need more answers, it needs the real answers

Phil Cobb
In the overwhelming majority of stories reported by this newspaper, the facts are cut and dry.
All sources are typically and readily accessible and the truth is near the surface.
Not so with what I believe is the most important story this newspaper has reported on in quite some time.
In late summer, the Nodaway County Senior Center Senate learned that for the first time in three decades the nutrition site would not receive state and federal funds distributed by the Northwest Missouri Area Agency on Aging.
That has resulted in about $150,000 less in the Senior Center’s budget for the 2017-18 fiscal year, and according to Senior Center Administrator Amie Firavich’s comments at a recent Maryville Host Lions Club meeting, it means there are, altogether, about 60 seniors, who were getting a hot meal once a day — either delivered by a volunteer through Meals on Wheels or in person at the nutrition site — who are now either choosing other options or going without.
In many cases people who were receiving the hot meals, prepared at the Senior Center and delivered by volunteers, are now getting a week’s worth of frozen meals delivered by a paid employee from St. Joseph — some are right next door to someone still getting a volunteer-delivered hot meal.
Inefficiency at its best.
The Maryville Daily Forum has published multiple stories on this topic over the past couple of months, but was unable to get comment from NWMOAAA Chief Executive Officer Rebecca Flaherty … until now.
Following the recent Host Lions Club meeting in which Missouri 12th District Senator Dan Hegeman and First District State Representative Allen Andrews were the featured guests, Maryville Daily Forum reporter Tom Pinney took it upon himself to elicit a response from Flaherty.
Flaherty did finally respond, giving Pinney the opportunity to present her with two questions that have been at the forefront of the resulting local discussion. 1. Why was the Nodaway County bid rejected? 2. What happened to the money that was coming to Nodaway County?
Here are Flaherty’s responses to those two questions from a typed email response to Pinney’s request:
Why was the Nodaway County bid rejected?
1. To give the Nodaway County Senior Center the opportunity to participate in a pilot project. The pilot was based on the need to identify and track outcomes for Older Americans Act Programs; address declining funding; and, to decrease the regulatory burden on local non-profits such as senior centers which restricts their ability to privatize services and implement innovative ideas for service provision.
To me, this makes it sound like the Senior Center was chosen for something they desired to “participate” in. I haven’t run across anyone locally who feels that way. And I’m not sure the word “participate” is applicable in this instance, as the local nutrition site ultimately isn’t “participating,” but instead being circumvented and essentially competed against.
What happened to the money that was coming to Nodaway County?
2. As stated previously, a portion of the funds NWMOAAA allocated to serve Nodaway County clients for the new grant year was awarded to the Maitland nutrition center to serve clients in the southern portion of the county. They have served clients in those areas for many years. The remaining Nodaway County allotment is being used to fund the frozen meal pilot for Nodaway County residents not served by Maitland. The Area Agency on Aging is providing these meals directly.
This is misleading at best. The Maitland nutrition center by Flaherty’s own admission was already being funded. If any of the Nodaway County Senior Center’s money went to Maitland, it has to have been a very small portion. That means the rest of it is going to the frozen meal “pilot” being administered by the agency through a different third party. After Medicaid dollars are removed, that is roughly $100,000.
This is where it should be noted that benefits, including compensation for the Area Agency actually increased.
To put it in a nutshell, a system that was by all accounts working, at least at satisfactory levels, has been replaced by a less efficient, more costly system that only works somewhat, for a portion of the people who were originally being served.
This is all a big tangled mess of confusion, misinformation and spin.
I am not satisfied with either of these answers.
I believe that if the truth were to be known, this is all the result of a clash of personalities between the Senior Center and the agency that has traditionally funded them, as the result of the vendetta of a disgruntled former employee.
Also through Pinney’s persistence, he came into contact with an anonymous source who tipped him off to an audit that was conducted in the spring, independently and directly by Flaherty of the local nutrition site.
Flaherty confirmed that she had conducted the audit, but declined to release the findings to the Daily Forum on advice from legal counsel.
As I write this, we are trying to get those results.
You can’t tell me that it’s a coincidence that an audit was performed and then the center was defunded for the only time in more than 30 years.
Flaherty initially welcomed further inquiries at Pinney’s request.
“Again, thank you for your inquiry. I or my public information officer would be happy to answer any questions that you might have after you have had an opportunity to review the attached information,” Flaherty said in her first email response. “We at the NWMOAAA appreciate that you are attempting to write a balanced story that discusses both sides of the issue as it relates to the challenges involved with serving more seniors with fewer dollars.”
However, in her third email to Pinney, Flaherty became defensive.
“Continuing to respond to the barrage of questions from reporters and elected officials regarding the Nodaway County pilot(s) has taken time and focus away from our Mission which is to serve eligible seniors, particularly those who are low-income and part of our target population with the resource available to us.”
Flaherty went so far as to question this newspaper’s motives.
“You seem to be looking for some sinister or unlawful reason (which is not the case) for attempting a pilot that would give the Nodaway County Senior Center the opportunity to participate in a pilot project based on the need to identify and track outcomes for Older Americans Act Programs; address declining funding; and, to decrease the regulatory burden on local non-profits such as senior centers which restricts their ability to privatize services and implement innovative ideas for service provision.”
I don’t care who is right in this situation. And unlike what appears to be the trend, even among some local media, this newspaper does not take sides.
I simply want the truth to come out.
For all I know, the senior center leadership might somehow be at fault for all this.
Let me be clear: I have no reason to believe that.
But if that’s the case, someone needs to say so.
Flaherty very clearly pointed out, “It is inaccurate to report that ‘their’ funding was cut. The funds distributed by the NWMOAAA belong to the NWMOAAA, not to an individual senior center.”
I don’t like the use of the word “belong,” maybe “the responsibility of” would be more accurate. She is right, though, but regardless of whose money it is now, it started out in the pockets of taxpayers.
Those taxpayers want to know the truth.
Phil Cobb is the owner and publisher of the Maryville Daily Forum and The Post.
