Skip to content

The end of the story

Tom Pinney

Yes, it’s taken me three weeks to tell a story that I teased in July. But it’s all worth it, and it all ties together.

Like How I Met Your Mother, I needed to tell you the story of how music shook me to my bones to talk about how it talked me off the ledge. Now comes the story of when songwriting became a hobby.

It was two weeks after the near-miss with the bread knife, and everything seemed to be clicking. In choir, we were nailing the “Noel” while learning the other pieces for our holiday concert. The speech season was two weeks old, and even though I hadn’t even sniffed a final round, I was having fun again.

The big problem in my life at that point was my ex.

We hadn’t talked since we broke up, and even though it was probably inevitable – since we lived 30 hours away from each other now – it still hurt like crazy. And I found myself in a semi-familiar place on that Wednesday night: alone in my room, noise on the radio, the family away at church while I had made the excuse of having just a ton of homework to do.

This time, the knife was safe in its normal spot in the kitchen. It wasn’t that dark of a place anymore, but it was still kind of painful.

A book had replaced the knife, one called The Battle of Jericho. It was a novel not based on the Bible story, about a kid named Jericho who tried to join a fraternal organization at his high school but was conflicted about whether he should tell the principal about the hazing the pledge class went through.

At the time, I wasn’t really paying attention to the book. Instead, my mind was replaying the last conversation I had with my ex, right when she told me it was over.

It was one of the hardest things to deal with, and I was still right in the middle of doing so. As I moved to turn off the radio to have some silence so that I could try to re-center myself mentally, my eyes wandered over my suicide note song, “Saying Goodbye.”

And for some reason, though I had seen it several times since I wrote it, something clicked in my brain. If writing this song and putting it to music could get me away from ending my life, maybe it could help me get over this relationship.

I went to my desk, grabbed some paper, and started to write down what I was feeling. I wrote about the pain in my heart, the dreams I had where we were still together, the disappointment I had that she was my first kiss and how I felt like I had wasted such a pivotal moment on someone who didn’t care.

Then I crumpled that piece of paper up, because it really seemed harsh, and I decided to go a different direction. What did I really want to say to her?

“I’m losing my mind thinking about you. Life’s going on, I know that much is true. The seasons change, but my feelings aren’t nearly as shifty.”

“About You” flowed from my heart to the page, and after two hours, half a box of tissues, and a small cut from when the E-string popped and ripped up my finger, I had a new song.

It was a couple of years before I shared the song with anyone, and when I did, I put it up on a Myspace page that I had created for my “band,” Doubt the Real. The point is, writing the song worked.

Several months later, I found myself falling for a girl again, and after about 30 minutes at home that night, “Feels like Falling” was my first love song.

I wanted to talk about songwriting for my Honors English class, so I wrote another song, “Bittersweet Paradise” to talk about my new home and how it seemed like a “home-adjacent.” I felt like a true songwriter because I was just writing songs for fun.

Meanwhile, my Myspace page (which I just feel like a dinosaur talking about) was starting to gain more followers from the area. People who I didn’t even know were talking about how they liked my voice and my writing style.

Then, I got a really cool message. The owner of the Scarlet and Gray, a bar on the edge of Ohio State’s campus in Columbus, contacted me and asked me to be an opener for the Local Showcase Thursday. It was my first paid gig, and even though my cut was only 30 percent of my own ticket sales (about $35 in total), it was so cool to call myself a professional artist.

A year later, the guy contacted me again and asked me to headline. This would be a much higher paying gig, but require more songs, and no more than 15 percent of my set could be covers. In return, I’d get 35 percent of ALL ticket sales for a 60-minute set.

Usually, artists would get 25 percent of the tickets and 10 percent of the bar, but since I was 17 at the time, I couldn’t profit from bar sales. I didn’t care. I was gonna get PAID.

And it was the beginning of the summer, so State was still in session but school wasn’t, so I wasn’t catching my friends on a school night and I was going to get some college kids to come out.

I got about $900 that night from the show, which ended up being my last paying gig. It all went into my savings account for my car.

That night, I realized something important about myself: if I was going to make a career out of this, I was going to hate it. I loved writing songs and performing. I couldn’t make this thing about the money when it was all about my own passion.

To this day, I still write songs every once in awhile. They’re in a journal that follows me wherever I go, just in case my muse finds me when I’m not at home.

It’s really one of the greatest hobbies a person can have, in my opinion. Songwriting has this hypnotic way of letting a person open themselves up without being ashamed of what’s inside.

If you’re ever interested in taking a listen, my latest songs are on YouTube. And no, they’re not metal. While I love listening to metal, I really enjoy playing in a light rock style, and if I ever put more instrumentation in my songs, they’re going to end up being very piano and acoustic heavy.

Mostly, though, those songs do a better job of explaining my feelings than my spoken words ever could.

Maybe writing songs could help you, too. It never hurts to try.

Tom Pinney is a news reporter for the Maryville Daily Forum.

Leave a Comment