My opportunity to participate in a discussion on free speech

Matt Pearl
I have been asked to remark upon the national phenomenon of professional athletes, specifically players in the NFL, taking a knee rather than standing and facing the flag during the pregame playing of the National Anthem.
While I’m certainly not an editorial jukebox, responding endlessly to whatever subject ‘button’ that others push, there are times when this column allows me the opportunity to participate in a discussion with folks who want to know what I am thinking.
On this issue, I think we are looking at a snapshot of America in the 2010s in a nutshell.
I liken the phenomenon to the celebrity, who takes the stage to accept his or her award on one of the nationally televised award shows, and then embarks upon a three-minute political rant. As viewers, we sometimes ask ourselves, ‘Why do these movie stars think we want to hear all of this?’
I would prefer that professional athletes not use a nationally televised sporting event to protest racial injustice by opting not to stand for the National Anthem. I am also trying to remember how often the media even showed players during the anthem before athletes began taking a knee. Something my Communication Theories instructor, Fred Lamer, taught me years ago has proven itself to be true time and time again: The medium is the message.
We are fixated upon whatever it is the television cameras choose as our next obsession. Remember that. Be objective in your thinking. If the cameras ignored this behavior, would it continue? If it weren’t being televised and perpetuated by the media, would you continue to care?
Don’t misinterpret the preceding remarks. I am not weighing in the on the value of the statement these athletes are making, nor am I suggesting that the media should or should not continue to cover the story. What I am suggesting is that our impressions of stories the media presents have the tendency to be sculpted by the specific way in which the media presents them.
It’s the reason that MSNBC and Fox News can exist: each can take the same kernel of truth and grow its own unique plant. For certain of the more liberal crowd, the Black Lives Matter movements is receiving needed attention thanks to the statements being made by the NFL players this fall and last.
For the conservatives, the anti-American message accompanying the kneeling during the Anthem undermines any political statement that the athletes themselves are trying to make.
I see the irony: the foundation of these young men’s right to free speech is the U.S. Constitution, which outlines the organizing principles of our nation. When an athlete kneels during the National Anthem rather than saluting the flag, in the minds of many he or she is using his or her American freedom to insult the very source of free speech. It has a distastefulness to it.
But it is that protester’s right. As a free citizen, I am allowed to question whether the protesters’ actions are appropriate, or whether they conform to my standard that an American citizen should hold.
I cannot question his American right to kneel, protest or use his position of fame to present his views. It’s absolutely none of my business to tell another human being whether or not to show respect to the American Flag. I just regret that we live in a land where folks feel so disrespected and disenfranchised that the flag offends them.
Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany, and Grant City.
