Thelma’s ice cream sandwiches come to Maryville

PHIL COBB/DAILY FORUM
Maryville Hy-Vee store director Travis Buysse shows off a case of Thelma’s handmade ice-cream sandwiches now available at the local supermarket. The new product is part of an effort by Hy-Vee to support local and regional brands.
Hy-Vee has always supported local, as well as, regional entrepreneurs. To that end, the Maryville store is carrying a new frozen treat just in time for the hottest part of summer.
Des Moines, Iowa-based Thelma’s handmade ice cream sandwiches are now available at the Maryville Hy-Vee, and store director Travis Buysse says he is excited to have them.
“We love featuring local entrepreneurs at Hy-Vee,” Buysse said. “Thelma’s is based in Des Moines, which is within 200 miles, and they have a great product.
“They’ve sold well so far here, and when I worked in Des Moines, they were always going quickly. It’s a great product, and it’s always nice to have a bit of ice cream during the summer.”
The Maryville location started carrying Thelma’s treats about a month ago, but Thelma’s owner Dereck Lewis said that Hy-Vee began carrying them in Des Moines in 2013.
“Hy-Vee is unique in that you can just go into a few stores and sell if you would like,” Lewis said. “They work very well with small businesses and local retailers.
“Hy-Vee was our first wholesale marketplace, other than our physical location. It’s nice to be working with them on selling our product.”
Thelma’s is named for Lewis’ great-grandmother Thelma, who he credits as the inspiration behind the company.
“She was born in 1904 and lived to be 108 years old,” Lewis said. “We started the business in 2012, so she got to see the business begin.
“Our biggest seller is our snickerdoodle, which is based on her recipe. It’s not like a top secret recipe, it’s probably in the cookbook at the church in Monroe.”
Thelma’s started out selling cookies at the Downtown Des Moines Farmers Market in the spring of 2012. As the spring turned into summer, Lewis thought about also making a frozen treat.
“Warm cookies and milk are great anytime, but they’re less popular in hotter weather,” Lewis said. “I wanted to make sure we were keeping up with the trend.
“I had a friend with an ice cream store in Monroe, and he suggested putting some ice cream between two cookies. So, we did it, and we started selling them, and they took off.”
Once again, the snickerdoodle took over sales and became the most popular sandwich. Made with vanilla ice cream, it’s just one of the offerings.
Hy-Vee is also carrying the more unusual flavors of sugar cookies with coffee ice cream, double chocolate chip cookies with mint ice cream, and peanut butter chocolate chip cookies with chocolate ice cream. In addition, Hy-Vee has chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream, sugar cookies with strawberry ice cream, and double chocolate cookies with chocolate ice cream.
In addition to the wholesale ice cream sandwiches at regional Hy-Vee locations, Thelma’s has a store in Des Moines which delivers warm cookies and milk around the metropolitan area.
