Skip to content

My take on retail closures: It isn’t all bad

TONY BROWN/DAILY FORUM
The Maryville J.C. Penney clothing and housewares store, long one of the anchor businesses at the Maryville Mall complex on South Main, is one of nearly 140 Penney’s locations that the iconic retail chain plans to shutter early this summer.

JC Penney and Payless ShoeSource recently announced they will be closing many of their stores nationally, and Maryville made the list of cuts for both stores.

At first glimpse, this can make it seem like Maryville can’t sustain them.

I’m going to go ahead and say, that’s just not true.

Both of those national retailers, along with an extensive list of others, have been failing for a while, and it was probably inevitable that they would go under at some point.

A recent article from Business Insider (link to full story at the bottom of the article) called it a “retail apocalypse,” but I would say it’s more of a retail adjustment.

The article said the United States “has 23.5 square feet of retail space per person, compared with 16.4 square feet in Canada and 11.1 square feet in Australia, the next two countries with the most retail space per capita, according to a Morningstar Credit Ratings report from October.”

I believe we are seeing the results of saturation of an overabundance of the same products carried by too many retailers, all trying to price each other out of business. Instead they’ve put themselves in a hole and can’t climb back out without declaring bankruptcy or paring down their stores and inventory.

And I get it, when they are sitting in an office in a city with hundreds of thousands, or even millions of people, a store in a city with 10,000 people is going to be the first to go.

They don’t always understand how closing down stores in towns our size can make a bigger impact than in their budding metropolis.

To those of us in smaller towns, places like this closing have a proportionately bigger impact on the jobs of our neighbors and the tax dollars we use to maintain and improve our infrastructure.

But instead of looking at it in only a negative light, we have to see it as an opportunity.

This is an opportunity for our economic developers to bring in new or different retailers that they identify as a need for this community.

This is an opportunity for local citizens to become entrepreneurs.

This is an opportunity to have the discussion about the importance of shopping locally.

Look at the number of locally-owned boutique and unique gift stores that have opened in the past year.

We’ve got other national retailers locating here right now – Shoe Sensation, Scooters Coffee, Boulders Inn and Suites, now a new Hallmark store inside Westlake Ace Hardware. And I have no doubt more are on the way.

The Greater Maryville Chamber of Commerce had more than 30 ribbon cuttings in 2016 for a very wide variety of businesses.

Retailers are seeing our community as a place they want to invest … they’re just not the same retailers we’ve seen in those spots for the past 20-plus years.

To everything there is a season. Just as people were probably mad when these corporately owned stores came in and took business from local mom and pop stores, the masses of certain retail trends are going under, as boutiques and online shopping surface.

It’s not all bad, just different.

I’ve heard a number of people say, “well I never went in there, but it’s sad to see them go.”

Change is not always a bad thing. Change brings opportunity for growth and to try something new.

Maybe instead of looking at these closures as detrimental, we look at them as an opportunity to bring something new and fresh to the community – something we can’t get in a short drive to St. Joe.

Maybe if we have something different, we’ll attract more outside tax dollars and a business that is more connected to the local community and to the Chamber of Commerce.

As someone who works with businesses in advertising and with the Chamber, I often see a direct connection between whether or not a business advertises and is involved in the community to whether or not they are successful.

Not always, but more often than not.

Maryville is a special place where people still want to know the people who run and work in the stores, and corporate America doesn’t always understand that. We want to feel invested in their businesses, as we should, but it’s hard when the businesses don’t invest in our community. A mix of locally-owned and nationally-recognized brands is important to a town, but being a part of the community is important no matter what the business is.

The shopping climate has changed, no doubt.

I also believe the online market makes it much easier to search and buy exactly what we are looking for instead of shopping around. That won’t change at this point, but we can all make an effort to visit our local retailers.

That’s right, our local retailers.

To those saying “we have nowhere in Maryville to shop now,” I wholeheartedly, and respectfully, disagree.

In fact, we have a growing number of locally-owned retailers right now. It’s incredibly exciting.

If they don’t have exactly what you’re looking for, meet them, and let them know what you’re looking for. Maybe others are too, and maybe they can fill a need that will help their business flourish.

That’s the beauty of getting to know the people behind the business, you can form a relationship that helps you and them both.

Another reason we’re seeing a decline in nationally-owned retail, is that we are now seeing a trend of spending money on experiences instead of material things.

I for one, welcome it, because I think doing activities or having experiences with our loved ones are much more important than filling our homes with a bunch of material things. We are becoming more conscientious about our purchases, which I think is smart.

But when we do make those purchases, be informed about what Maryville has to offer.

Look around, pay attention to the business community and local news.

It takes all of us to collectively help a community thrive.

Let’s pay attention to our local entrepreneurs.

Let’s be supportive of the new retail and restaurant options our economic developers are bringing to our community.

They see us all as worth their investment. Let’s offer them the same courtesy.

You guys, Maryville has so much going for it right now. Let’s not focus on the couple of bad things, and instead tell all of the good stories happening in this town as we speak.

(Article mentioned in column: http://www.businessinsider.com/the-retail-apocalypse-has-officially-descended-on-america-2017-3?utm_content=buffer77d60&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer)

TOM PINNEY/DAILY FORUM
The Payless ShoeSource in Maryville, located in the Maryville Center next to Sutherlands, looks ready for customers. On Tuesday, Payless’ corporate offices announced the closure of the Maryville store, as well as close to 400 other stores in the United States and Puerto Rico, as part of the process for filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

Leave a Comment