Skip to content

The Electoral College protects the rural vote

Matt Pearl

I was watching my alma mater, Northwest Missouri State, winning its second straight Division II National Championship on television Saturday, a broadcast during which there were several commercial spots featuring celebrities urging members of the Electoral College to consider ousting Trump as the President-Elect.

I have read a number of pieces and seen such spots on TV that have the same message, a protected bit of free speech that I happen to think the responsible party should be allowed to run. But from a step-back-and-see perspective, the whole movement to reject the election results begins to take on a ‘kicking and screaming’ quality.

Not that I’m particularly a Trump fan. I’m not. But there’s a point when I have to examine which event is more likely to be disruptive in the context of our democratic processes: to have elected a potentially bad commander-in-chief, or to have upset for certain a purpose and intent of the Electoral College.

One of those things we’ve tried: we have had leaders who did not measure up to the American standard of approval—quite a few times, actually. But the norms in place for choosing the President of the United States have remained intact.

So are we ready to do this, America? Are we ready to set a new precedent that the Electoral College has dictatorial control over presidential selection? Remember as you answer: someday, it could—will—be your candidate who wins, and then is ousted by political maneuvering.

To a foreign nation or news agency peeking at us from the outside, what would the perception be? What if America, by its established rules, elects its chief executive, then puts the competitor in office instead?

Well, turn the story on its flipside. Pretend this was an election in, say, Mexico. You read that the people elect a leader, then a few weeks later the headlines inform you that the challenging candidate is installed as president. What does it look like when other countries do it?

That being said, the Electoral College is absolutely given power to make a selection that conflicts with the will of the people. I would assume this process is in place to prevent the installation of a tyrant into the White House. I am certain Trump’s loudest opponents believe him to be such a dictator.

I suppose this entire situation depends upon your view of the United States. Are we a stable, unified group of citizens, or are we teetering upon widespread civil divide? I split the difference between the two extremes: I think we have great ideological differences that have us separated into two camps, conservative and liberal. But I think the bitter disputes that divided America in 1861 were greater than those we face today. Additionally, we are far better informed than the general population was then: we know the dangers of a military split in this country better than folks did then.

An Electoral College rejection of Trump would say to roughly half the voters in America: “It doesn’t matter what the rules are, or who you picked, this country has other ideas for the next four years.” Should that be the message? I don’t know. But it would be the message heard.

This issue, I believe, will fade away before long. But get used to hearing great continuing political opposition to the Electoral College’s role going forward. Just remember, if we transition to a popular vote scenario, rural America would never be capable of taking on the urban vote. A handful of major cities would choose our leader every four years.

Leave a Comment