Skip to content

How doubt gives birth to my belief in Christmas

Jennifer Ditlevson Haglund

In the middle of thousands of people viewing the iconic Christmas tree at Rockefeller Center last week, I almost had a panic attack. I’m not using hypberbole.

I couldn’t move, and I didn’t feel mesmerized as much as suffocated among masses of belted Michael Kors jackets and arms aloft snapping selfies. My husband led us from the crowd and to the nearest train, where I could breathe again. I couldn’t wait to leave Manhattan and return to our apartment in Queens.

Because of the success of movies like “Elf,” “When Harry Met Sally,” “Serendipity,” and “Home Alone II,” New York, particularly Manhattan, has become a holy land of cultural Christmas enchantment.

I never realized how much I counted on the commercial Christmas fairy tale of sparkle and excitement until I found myself losing faith in it.

I still decorate a Christmas tree, and every year I construct a seasonal display with a few things for the holiday near the living or eating area. The Advent wreath I made four years ago sits on the dinner table.

All the glitter and programmed lights and music of the Saks Fifth Avenue window display, however, couldn’t restore my Christmas cheer this year. It would take a miracle — or at least, remembering the miracle that started this whole business of Christmas.

For me, gold-embossed words like “belief,” “joy,” and “goodwill,” printed on shopping bags and displays seem inspirational and positive, but their promises are abstract and empty. I don’t know when the disenchantment started, but I have noticed in the last five years that every time I hear those Nat King Cole, Burl Ives, and Mariah Carey songs repeat and start to see advertisements for all things peppermint and gingerbread, I find myself disappointed.

I’m not against celebration, but I wonder if the magic in the air people crave is to hide the dim reality of a world where the color of a person’s skin or the religion they do or do not follow dictates their safety. “Goodwill to men” doesn’t materialize in the holiday season after Thanksgiving through the New Year just because of some periodic wizardry. That lie obscures the intent of that first Christmas in Bethlehem.

The Gospel of Luke details the folk history and spectacle of the shepherds and angels announcing Jesus’ birth, but the event wasn’t ideal or notable to many that night. To most, Jesus was an illegitimate son born to an unfortunate couple. An oppressive government required the young mother of seemingly questionable virtue and a laborer to travel in uncomfortable circumstances to register for the occupying authority’s census, and the child was born in a barn. Almost from birth, he lived on the run in hiding from Herod’s decree of genocide.

Considering a year full of so much violence, in Aleppo or in the United States, this unassuming, almost forgettable Christmas revives my weary heart.

The upending of the expectation of a savior who would come in glory, serve retribution, and restore political power in one tiny child gives me hope but makes me weep. It seems so simple and yet absurd that the Christmas child grew into a man who lived that mystery of peaceful, sacrificial truth and inexhaustible, unconditional love.

We all need a break and could use something light and sweet. But manufactured Christmas is such an easy distraction from the humility of a God who came to experience life on earth as human, in all its sorrow and injustice. Emmanuel, “God with us,” has always been my favorite name for Christ. It reminds me that God is better at being human than people are at inventing and capturing the nature of the divine.

Leave a Comment