Royals’ Dayton Moore is in a tough spot

Phil Cobb
The Kansas City Royals are in a difficult position.
General Manager Dayton Moore is faced with the prospect of losing most of his core of championship-caliber players — many of the same players who helped him claim a World Series title barely over a year ago.
Should he stand pat and risk getting nothing in return for free agents Eric Hosmer, Mike Moustakas, Lorenzo Cain, Alcides Escobar, Wade Davis, Danny Duffy, Jarrod Dyson, and Jason Vargas following the 2017 season?
It’s possible the team could be without all those players as it enters spring training in 2018. If they all leave via free agency, especially under the newly-agreed-upon collective bargaining agreement, the team could get pretty much nothing in return.
It stands to reason if Moore were to go that route, adding a few key pieces, the team could throw everything in to 2017 and make a very solid run toward another championship.
However, the team operated under a record-high payroll last season, and is likely to do so again in the coming year. Adding pieces from the free agent market would most likely be out of the question.
But what if the Royals could make a run for a title in 2017, and at the same time, position itself to be competitive in 2018 and beyond?
That’s Moore’s stated goal.
It sounds like he’s just telling us what we want to hear, but it’s the absolute truth … he wants to make the team better now and in the future.
The way to do that, as painful as it sounds, is to part with some of the core pieces.
As I write this, it is being reported that the Chicago Cubs have traded Jorge Soler to the Royals for closer Wade Davis.
I know people who will completely melt down over this.
And honestly, I hope we’re getting more than just Soler.
But the bottom line is, that Wade Davis is not going to be a member of this team in 2018 … no matter what.
So, if we can get something for him, I think it’s good.
From what I’ve read about Soler, he is kind of like a younger version of Lorenzo Cain — pure athletic ability with raw baseball skills.
Scouts believe that Soler, at 6-4 and 225 pounds, will be more of a power bat and less of a go-get-it outfielder than Cain, but he has yet to break out.
Some have compared him to Mark Trumbo of the Baltimore Orioles, and have projected him as a 30-homer kind of guy.
He has yet to play a full season, topping out at 101 games for the Cubs in 2015.
That year, he hit 10 home runs and drove in 47 runs in 404 plate appearances.
Battling injury last season, he hit 12 homers and drove in 31 in barely over half a season.
He will likely become the Royals right fielder.
I’m assuming Moore has a plan to replace Davis in the bullpen, and I hope that plan involves former Royals closer Greg Holland, and Moore’s primary stated goal was to recreate a lock-down bullpen, and with the loss of Davis, that creates a huge void to fill.
Of course, the Royals have internal options to help build the bullpen.
I know they consider Matt Strahm as that type of arm, but I’m kind of hoping he will make it to the starting rotation.
Maybe the hottest pitcher in house is Josh Staumont, who is currently on the Double A roster at Northwest Arkansas.
Scouts are saying he has the best arm in the organization, and he has recently been slotted as the team’s top minor league prospect, with the potential to break camp with the club out of spring training.
Again, I hope the Royals got more than just Soler in return for Davis, but this is the type of deal the Royals should be looking at.
Kelvin Herrera will immediately move to the team’s closer role, and will automatically be one of the top closers in baseball. Getting to him might be the problem.
Team’s have shown interest in Lorenzo Cain and Jarrod Dyson.
I would think KC could get a haul for Cain, who has pretty much been the Royals best overall player for the past two seasons.
I can’t imagine we would get much in return for Dyson, but stranger things have happened.
I think we should be shopping Mike Moustakas.
For a team trying to limit payroll, it has two, much more affordable options in Hunter Dozier and Cheslor Cuthbert.
Maybe a package including Moose and Dyson could return a solid starting pitcher.
I think that, and a bat to replace departed designated hitter Kendrys Morales should be at the top of Moore’s wish list as he continues to navigate the postseason waters.
Just don’t get too upset if we have to say goodbye to some familiar faces.
