Should we tax our fellow citizens for their legal vices?

Matt Pearl
Perhaps making sweeping generalizations holds a few risks, but this week I think I can make just one without any real reservations.
Legislation that taxes “vice” – cigarettes, gambling, alcohol, etc. – and promises to give the proceeds to education never ultimately benefits kids or teachers.
Remember in the 1990s when the riverboat gambling money was going to go to education? It did! But then our politicians robbed from the foundation formula’s guaranteed education money for a net benefit to public schools of nothing.
Now we have the newest incarnation of the tax-vice-for-something-nice movement: called ‘Amendment 3’, this issue on your Nov. 8 ballot would tax cigarettes on an incrementally increasing scale until the tax reached its peak in 2020.
As always, the pitch is the same: tax cigarettes more (Missouri’s tobacco taxes are relatively low), fund education and everybody (except the smoker) is happy.
I have no problem with the wording or intent of the proposed law. My trouble is one born out of pessimism, and my pessimism is born of observation and experience. My instincts tell me that, ultimately, education in Missouri will not benefit much, if any, from this law.
And as a teacher and observer of humanity, I can tell you that smokers will pay – no matter what the tax on tobacco. They’re not smoking for economic reasons; they’re smoking because they want to smoke.
I have seen students go without things while parents spent their money on cigarettes. I don’t approve of this, but there is a limit to how much of my judgments I can impose on others. Still, increasing cigarette taxes will translate into many impoverished Missourians living on less.
I know what many folks would say: If they would just quit smoking they’d have more money. Perhaps this statement is true, but to what end? Have you ever successfully talked a smoker out of smoking by using an argument based upon household economics?
And that’s why these types of “vice” taxes come up from time to time. We can’t talk smokers out of smoking, so let’s tax them for their trouble. If the taxpayers approve it, then we establish something with which I fundamentally contend: that a group of voters can force other people to pay taxes on a completely legal (if not entirely healthy) addictive substance.
Is it really noble to show our disapproval for tobacco use by voting to tax other people for their tobacco habits? Does lying to ourselves and pretending that we’re going to use the money to beef up education really make things right?
I am not a smoker. For the sake of every loved one I’ve ever lost to lung cancer, emphysema or heart disease, I wish cigarettes had never been invented. Profiteering from selling addictive sticks of cancer-causing, lung-destroying garbage seems wrong – but it’s legal. Selling them. Smoking them. It’s all legal.
When our desire to impose our ethics upon others puts us in the role of tax policy dictators over our fellow citizens, we’re blurring the lines between morality and legality.
And besides, I have every confidence that for every dollar that Amendment 3 would move toward Missouri public education, our politicians will find a way to rob another dollar from schools and sink into whatever passes for good policy these days. Vote with your own conscience on this one, folks, but my vote will be a “No.”
