Cigarette tax measures not what they may seem

Anthony Brown
Rep. Allen Andrews
I always do my best to write my capitol report with a respectful and balanced approach to both sides of every issue. However, I have a great deal of concern over the following two measures that will be seen on the upcoming November ballot regarding an increase to cigarette taxes. You see, the ballot language sounds wonderful and leads one to think the increased taxes will do a great deal of good. In actuality, these measures are very misleading and are heavily backed by big tobacco themselves. Embedded in these ballot measures are profit-driven initiatives that have the potential to do much more harm than good. That’s why they are opposed by health-care groups that typically support tobacco tax increases including the American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network, American Heart Association, American Stroke Association, American Lung Association, Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, Health Care Foundation of Greater Kansas City and Tobacco-Free Missouri as well as such groups as Concerned Women for America of Missouri, Missouri Alliance for Freedom and United for Missouri. Following, I will layout both sides of these initiatives for your review. I encourage you to always conduct your own research on every ballot measure prior to casting your vote.
Constitutional Amendment 3 – Cigarette Tax Increase for Early Childhood Education
Constitutional Amendment 3 is one of two proposals on the ballot that would increase the tax on cigarettes. Amendment 3 would increase taxes on cigarettes until 2020 when the total increase would reach 60 cents per pack of 20. The amendment also would create a 67-cent per pack fee for wholesalers to pay on certain cigarettes.
If approved by voters the amendment would generate between $263 million and $374 million each year. The additional revenues would be placed in an Early Childhood Health and Education Trust Fund and utilized for early childhood education.
Supporters of the proposal say Missouri lags behind other states in providing state-funded preschool programs. They also note that Missouri currently has the lowest tax on cigarette sales in the country. Missouri currently taxes cigarettes at the rate of 17 cents per pack while the national average is at $1.65 per pack. Opponents have raised concerns that the proposal is a “tax scheme” that will divert money away from public K-12 schools and allow for public funds to be used by private schools. They also note that language in the proposal would restrict the funding from being used for the enforcement of tobacco laws and smoking cessation programs. Additionally, the funds raised by the measure would be allocated by an unelected commission rather than by the normal appropriations process.
Proposition A – Cigarette Tax Increase for Transportation Infrastructure
The second cigarette tax increase proposal on the November ballot would slowly increase the tax per pack and then use the additional revenue to fund transportation infrastructure projects in Missouri. Proposition A would increase the tax on each pack of cigarettes by 13 cents in 2017, by 5 cents in 2019, and by another 5 cents in 2021. The total increase would amount to 23 cents for a total tax in Missouri of 40 cents per pack of 20. The proposal would also increase the tax that sellers pay on other tobacco products by 5 percent of the manufacturer’s invoice price.
When fully implemented, the tax increases would generate approximately $95 million to $103 million each year. The money would then be placed in a Transportation Infrastructure Fund to be used for road repairs throughout the state.
Both tax increase measures have been opposed by groups like the American Cancer Society and the American Heart Association, which say neither tax increase is big enough. Some groups also take issue with the fact the campaigns for both measures are supported by tobacco companies.
Constitutional Amendment 3 has received financial support from big tobacco companies like R.J. Reynolds, while Proposition A has received support from smaller cigarette companies. The small companies have opposed Constitutional Amendment 3 because of the 67 cents per pack fee increase that is directed at them. Backers of Amendment 3 say the fee increase is meant to close a loophole that has allowed small companies to avoid making payments to 46 states mandated by a multi-state court settlement to help offset Medicaid costs.
If both measures were to be approved by voters, Missouri law says the proposal with the greater number of affirmative votes would take effect, but the final outcome would likely be decided in court.
As always, it is an honor to represent you!
Allen Andrews, State Representative – District 1, Missouri State Capitol, Room 135AB, 201 West Capitol Avenue, Jefferson City, MO 65101. Telephone: 573-751-9465. [email protected]
