Skip to content

Kaepernick sparks freedom of speech debate

Before a preseason National Football League matchup between the San Francisco 49ers and the Green Bay Packers played in Levi’s Stadium last Friday night, 49ers backup quarterback Colin Kaepernick decided not to rise or put his hand over his heart for the National Anthem.

After the game, according to NFL.com, Kaepernick was approached by a reporter about his decision, to which he replied, “I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color.

“To me, this is bigger than football and it would be selfish on my part to look the other way. There are bodies in the street and people getting paid leave and getting away with murder.”

As a result, social media exploded with both supporters and opponents of Kaepernick’s views and choice of protest.

Brian Swafford, Director of Forensics and instructor in the Department of Communication and Mass Media at Northwest Missouri State University with an emphasis on sports rhetoric, says the question of the appropriateness of Kaepernick’s actions boils down to three key issues.

Swafford’s first question was if Kaepernick has the right to do what he did.

“Yes,” Swafford said. “Quite obviously, he has the right to sit down during the Anthem, and people who oppose him have the right to express their opposition.”

Swafford’s second point dealt with the appropriateness of protesting the flag and the National Anthem.

“This part is a little fascinating,” Swafford said. “One of the main arguments is that this disrespects the military. That argument assumes the performance of the Anthem or salute of the flag is inherently supportive of the military.

“That’s just not true; look at every time the Anthem was performed during the Olympics. That was a show of support for the country, yes, but it was a celebration of the accomplishments of the athlete, not the military.”

Past that, Swafford said, topics of protest get a little dicey because “the method of protest is easier to critique than the reason someone is protesting.”

“The problem lies in the contradictory way that people are saying disadvantaged people can protest,” Swafford explained. “Look at the aftermath of Ferguson and Baltimore [the riots for Freddie Gray], people were saying they should find a peaceful way of protesting.

“[Kaepernick] didn’t make a big deal out of what he was doing, and he didn’t seek out the media’s attention after the fact. He found a peaceful way to protest, and now they’re saying he shouldn’t be protesting that way.

“So if they can’t protest with violence but they can’t protest with peace, then what is the proper protocol for protesting issues of social justice?”

Swafford then addressed the idea of Kaepernick’s status.

“They say he shouldn’t be protesting because he makes a lot of money,” Swafford said. “However, that doesn’t mean he doesn’t experience prejudice.

“You’re not immune from prejudiced or racist behavior if you’re popular. James Blake was a popular black tennis player who was tackled by police at a hotel during the U.S. Open because they thought he was a drug dealer.

“Look also at Thabo Sefolosha, [a basketball player for the Atlanta Hawks] who had his leg broken by police in an altercation in New York in April 2015. Racial profiling doesn’t stop when you gain a certain amount of celebrity or make a certain amount of money.”

Swafford said Kaepernick’s protest was “exactly what we [the American public] told him to do.”

“We critique athletes and celebrities if they don’t speak out about issues in this country,” Swafford said. “But now that Kaepernick is talking about this very uncomfortable subject, we’re basically saying he shouldn’t be speaking out about those issues.

“Kaepernick is at the center of several intersections where social justice is and should be active. That means, if the flag and the national anthem are so symbolic and evocative, then his protest shows exactly the gravity of the situation he and so many others see as pervasive in this society.”

Ultimately, according to Swafford, it comes down to parity when it comes to accepting the actions of people with higher statuses.

“If we laud them for giving money to charity …” Swafford said, “… we should laud them for being active for social justice and talking about the difficult issues. In many cases, social justice campaigns are just as important as charities.”

Leave a Comment