Church leaders express views on God, school
In June 1962, the United States Supreme Court ruled in Engel v. Vitale that a prayer recited at the beginning of every day in public schools in New York violated the First Amendment’s non-establishment clause.
Some believe this was the first shot toward the free exercise of Christianity in public schools, forever prompting the question of whether we should allow God to be put back in public schools. Films such as God’s Not Dead and its sequel brought this question back to the forefront of public discussion.
However, some area ministers believe the onus for personal religious observances in public spaces should not fall on the public institutions in question. Paul McKim, senior pastor at Laura Street Baptist Church, said students and teachers themselves are responsible for their relationship with God.
“The free exercise of faith is guaranteed to all,” McKim explained. “So each person needs to figure out what that means to them. We have measures in place to make sure people are free to practice, and those rights are not denied.”
In much the same way, Scott Moon, lead pastor at First United Methodist Church of Maryville, believes “God never left schools.”
“We are often not prone to recognizing the presence and work of God,” Moon said. “So we tend to limit our understanding of what God’s presence is. Even though it seems like the free expression is not acceptable, that doesn’t mean it stopped happening.”
Moon believes the changing times don’t change the personal responsibility inherent in the Christian faith.
“It is my job to be a faithful witness of my faith in a multi-religious, multi-cultural society,” Moon explained. “I’m not supposed to persuade or convince, I’m supposed to tell my story and let God work in the way only He can.
“It’s not the job of the public schools to change lives.”
Atlas Oliver, youth and family pastor at Countryside Christian Church, feels a bit differently on the matter.
“It seems like education rejects the idea of faith-based lives,” Oliver said. “Some within the world of education believe it isn’t modern, it isn’t relatable.
“However, the education system seems to be more open and sensitive to other religions.”
When it comes to putting God back in schools, Oliver says it boils down to a “fairness factor.”
“Putting God back in schools would mean students get a complete education on what is out there,” Oliver explained. “I don’t think this is for every class, but it would be strange if something with educational merit wasn’t allowed for some reason.”
Events like See You At The Pole in late September and clubs like Fellowship of Christian Athletes are good for schools, but Oliver said they can feel “sterilized” because of strict public education regulations.
“These can be a great stepping stone to put God back in schools, but they can also be really hard to buy into because they feel watered down,” Oliver said.
McKim said the freedom of religion meant that people of all religious faiths needed to be free to practice in the way they see fit. “I’m not in favor of mandating one single expression of faith; it takes away the freedom that we enjoy. We can’t limit free expression to one set of believers.”
Susan Martin, principal at St. Gregory’s School, says this is the issue with public schools.
“With public schools, you have to talk about every religion and have free expression for all,” Martin said. “To let one religion in, you have to provide equal treatment to all others, which may create more controversy than it solves.”
Father Martin Demeulenaere, pastor at St. Gregory’s Catholic Church, said that’s why parochial schools still exist and enjoy success.
“We have the freedom [at St. Gregory’s School] to show preference to Christianity, and you can notice a visible difference in the attitudes of our students,” Father Martin explained.
From an educational standpoint, C3 Maryville elder and former first-grade teacher at Eugene Field Elementary Brian Herndon explained that religiosity in schools was a “tricky” area.
“I’m for students participating in their own practices, but I’m against state-sponsored religious instruction,” Herndon said. “There are so many different interpretations and denominations out there that, if they choose one of them, they leave out all the others, and if they present all of them, it becomes very confusing on young minds.”
Herndon explained it had nothing to do with being opposed to different viewpoints.
“Children need a foundation of understanding before they are bombarded with conflicting information when it comes to religion,” Herndon said. “In order to get that, it’s really the responsibility of parents and churches to establish that foundation.”
