Skip to content

Farmer’s Mutual Insurance celebrates 125 years in Nodaway County

Jennifer Ditlevson Haglund
The Farmers Mutual Insurance Company of Nodaway County Board of Directors includes Bob Hall, Steve Miller, Ron Howard, Terry Nicholas, Onedia Wolverton, and Tricia Wiederholt.

With Farmers Mutual Insurance Company of Nodaway County celebrating its 125th anniversary of business, the company’s legacy runs deep, with a heritage that can honestly claim the “family business” title.

In 1891, the company was first organized in Burlington Junction as the Farmers Mutual Fire and Lightning Insurance Company. In the past century, the individually operated local companies have been handed down through generations of agents who knew about farming, and about the assets that needed to be protected.

“There was a void out there at a point in time when people living in the country were unable to have insurance protection for the assets that they had,” Nodaway Valley Bank Senior Vice President Bob Hall said. “That’s why the company sought out farmers to be agents.”

Hall, who is a fourth-generation agent at Farmers Mutual, said he remembers hearing about when his grandfather, Eugene, sold his first policy for $2.50 to a neighbor who had a good team of horses. Years later, when Bob became an insurance agent, he talked to the same man who still had policies with the company.

“When you take over a family business, there’s some pressure, and there’s some pride,” said Hall. “It makes you do a better job, honestly.”

Hall’s son, Daron, continues the family line of work to the fifth generation.

Agent Steve Miller has family history with the company that began in 1936 when his grandfather Floyd Miller, served on the board.

“I can still remember the night my father became an insurance man,” said Miller.

Recounting the story, Miller said he was 6 years old, waiting at St. Francis Hospital to hear about his grandfather’s health. When Steve’s father, Max, came out with the report, he announced that he would be taking over the family business. Max served on the company’s board, as did his father before him, for 30 years.

Miller described himself as a “fairly successful farmer” when his father asked him to take over the business in 1996. At the time, he had no interest in adding “agent” to his job title.

“But thinking back, I was the obvious choice,” said Miller, recalling the time he spent with his father, driving around the country around Graham in a pickup truck making calls.

“I guess father saw something in me then,” he said.

Since he bought the business, Miller has been able to grow his clientele substantially. He said he owes some of the success to having an established business, but he also said Farmers Mutual agents are acutely aware of the stigma salespeople carry.

“I’m more in the service industry than sales,” Miller said. “And I think that would ring true with everybody else.”

Tricia Wiederholt didn’t think she would buy the business from her father, John Riley, either, but she said the opportunity presented itself at the right time in 2002.

Wiederholt and her husband, Jeff, run the business from their home in the country outside Ravenwood, where Jeff farms full time, and helps with the insurance business when he can.

Sharing a background in farming, according to Wiederholt, also puts some clients at ease because the agents personally understand their needs.

While Miller has been an agent, he’s had to make several claims on his own property, including roof and siding repairs, and a total loss on a shed fire. In August 2011, after widespread hail damage destroyed property across the county, Farmers Mutual paid about $20 million in response to 2,000 claims made within a week’s time, according to Pam Spire, company manager at Farmer’s Mutual Insurance Company of Nodaway County.

Over the years, the company has adapted to market demands. In 1966, the company followed the Missouri Division of Insurance regulations to sell all types of insurance, not just fire and lightning protection.

Wiederholt said it’s a common misconception that the company only insures farms.

“We can insure about anything you need to insure,” she said.

Now, Farmers Mutual is the largest insurance provider in the state operating under Chapter 380, which regulates county, town, and farmers mutual property insurance companies. Both Hall and Miller said it’s time to consider what the 125 years might bring.

“We are a very strong company, always ready for a change,” said Wiederholt.

Keeping the business local, according to Hall, helps to create goodwill and relationships that further the company’s continuity. All the board of directors live in the county, and the underwriting and most adjusting takes place locally as well.

“It’s just good business,” Hall said.

At one time, agents had their own territory to sell, but within the last 30 years, they began selling wherever they wished. Although the agents are competitors, Miller said it’s a congenial community.

“We would do anything for each other,” he said. “Only in rural America does this kind of thing work.”

To thank policyholders, Farmers Mutual will host a barbecue from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. Friday at the Maryville office at 311 E. Summit Dr.

SUBMITTED PHOTO
This photo from the late 1980s shows several board members and agents whose children now work for the company. From back left, John Riley, Lowell Weland, Clyde Beattie, Max Miller, Dean James. Front, from left, Terry Nichols, Ed Brown, Diane West, Doris Roberts, Brice Hall

Leave a Comment