Skip to content

Too many cooks spoil the broth

Matt Pearl

Our friends at the Maryville Daily Forum recently published a story detailing the teacher shortage that is becoming truly serious in northwest Missouri. I’ll not synopsize the entire story, but the gist was that our state — through testing procedures for would-be teachers and through school finance practices — put small schools behind the proverbial eight ball.

The article focused on Nodaway County schools, particularly the non-Maryville districts. But the remarks made by the school administrators in the story would likely echo our own local superintendents’ thoughts on the shortage.

I recently left my full-time teaching gig, and I reserve the possibility to instruct in a part-time capacity if the right situation presents itself. But having departed from the field, I can offer some perspective.

First, to the communities reading, you must realize that there is a philosophical separation between the majority of elementary teachers and their secondary (high school) counterparts. I say this without criticism: it stands to reason that teaching a first-grade class requires a different set of skills from instructing sophomores.

Teachers within a district generally get along, but the gulf dividing elementary and secondary educators can be vast. In general, the elementary teaching crew has greater appreciation for professional development exercises: the science of implementing teaching techniques for young people is first and foremost, and this makes sense, particularly when we look at a small school elementary teacher’s typical day. Each one teaches a multitude of subjects from a variety of textbooks, using a variety of methods based upon the discipline being taught, and thus view teaching from the methodology standpoint.

High school teachers tend to be more specialized in their academic disciplines. Math teachers love math, for example. They know math. A talented math instructor has a method for relating that information to a student, and (in general) does not feel the need for continuous instruction from the district on how the material should be taught.

One way is not the right way. But the differences between teachers are what, in my observation, has kept our elementary staffs at small schools more constant in terms of personnel. Teachers tend to retire rather than quit. They sat longer, because being a public educator means that you will be frequently bombarded with professional development techniques, changes and work. Elementary educators don’t mind it so much. High school teachers are a little more, well, proprietary of their knowledge.

And on the surface, I’m sure it looks like just plain pride and stubbornness. And sometimes, that’s probably what it is. But as a former high school teacher, I offer a metaphor that illustrates the trouble with hiring and keeping good high school personnel:

Imagine you are opening a high-classed restaurant, and you hire educated, experienced chefs to prepare the food for your customers. But when your culinary artists arrive for their first day on the job, the manager hands them a recipe for one menu item that got high marks in another different restaurant.

Why hire a team of professional chefs to cook one dish that’s supposed to work for everyone? Isn’t the point of having food preparation masters in the house to prepare a variety of quality choices based upon each chef’s individual expertise? Your chef might be better off taking a job as a cashier somewhere else — and I suspect pursuing jobs outside teaching is what too many teachers are doing.

Leave a Comment