Skip to content

Grand Obstructionist Party attempting to rewrite rules

Richard Fulton

Let me give a bit of a civics lesson.

First, to quote the Constitution of the United States: “The executive Power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America. He shall hold his Office during a Term of four years…”.

Then it says in Article II, Section 2: “… he shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint … Judges of the supreme Court ….”

The Constitution does not say that he “might” or “could” or even “should” make these appointments. It says he “shall” make the appointments. To do otherwise is to violate the Constitution.

No president has refused to make such appointments in fairly short order, let alone not do so because he has only a year left in office. There is no precedent for not making the nomination.

You can, I suppose, go back to the 1840s when the Senate refused to take up the nominations of President John Tyler: note that the majority then were Whigs. Not much of a precedent.

Since 1900, an article on the Supreme Court internet site notes, there has been no instance of a president not making a nomination to a vacant seat on the Court during election season for president AND the Senate not confirming a nomination.

The Grand Obstructionist Party is making up or misinterpreting any instance that might indicate otherwise. Period.

Election year appointments and confirmations?

A history lesson.

March 13, 1912 — President Taft nominated Mahlon Pitney, who was confirmed five days later.

Jan. 28, 1916 — Taft nominated Louis Brandeis, who was confirmed on June 1st.

July 14, 1916 — President Wilson nominated John Clarke; he was confirmed on the 24th of that year.

Feb. 14, 1932 — President Hoover nominated Benjamin Cardozo, who was confirmed ten days later.

Jan. 4, 1940 — President Roosevelt appointed Frank Murphy, then confirmed on Jan. 16.

Nov. 30, 1987 — President Reagan appointed Anthony Kennedy and on Feb. 3, a Democrat controlled Senate confirmed him. Note GOP, this is a good precedent to follow.

The Grand Obstructionists hardly let Justice Scalia’s blood get cold before they announced they would obstruct the constitutional processes for nominating a person to succeed him. They say that it is “standard practice” not to confirm a Supreme Court nominee during a presidential election year.

Yet, if they would go back to Ronald Reagan’s appointment of Justice Kennedy, he was confirmed in February of an election year with EVERY Republican and Democrat voting for him.

As the father in the great play (and movie) “Cat on a Tin Roof” ruminated, “there is the smell of mendacity in here.”

The GOP doesn’t even want to give the appearance of following the Constitution, they want no nomination, no confirmation vote.

What are they afraid of?

The American people?

They could hold hearings, have a vote and vote down the nominee. It’s been done.

But never has it been that the Supreme Court was left short of a full contingent for over a year.

Obama is President of the United States for a full four years, whether the Republicans like it or not.

They have denigrated the office as well as Obama since he was elected.

You argue with this?

Well think of it, never has history recorded a member of Congress shouting “you lie” to the president while giving the constitutionally prescribed duty of the State of the Union address.

Until Obama.

Let’s not let the GOP denigrate the Constitution as well.

Leave a Comment