Skip to content

Adult adoptees face challenges gaining access to records

ALANNA WOLF Staff Writer
Adult adoptees face challenges gaining access to records

EDITOR’S NOTE: This is the fourth and final story in a series of stories about north Missouri families and their experiences with different aspects of adoption. November is National Adoption Month.

By ALANNA WOLF

Staff Writer

Adoption can be a wonderful thing, but many adult adoptees in Missouri and other states face difficulties when trying to gain access to their original birth certificates or birth parents’ medical information.

Carolyn Pooler of Kansas City, adopted as an infant, is a case in point.

“When my granddaughter was born, she had a rather serious health issue,” Pooler said. “After genetic testing we figured out that the issue came from me, but I had no idea that health issue even existed in my biological family because I was never allowed access to my biological parents’ information.

“And then when I attempted to find that information to see if there were any other health issues I needed to be worried about, or to pass that genetic information on to my children, I wasn’t allowed access to my original birth certificate.”

Pooler eventually resorted to DNA testing and was able to connect with her biological mother’s family after considerable effort and paperwork.

“Due to Missouri’s closed adoption laws, it was a struggle for my maternal family to get information about me and vice versa,” Pooler said. “Even though they knew I existed and wanted to make contact, it was a very convoluted process to make direct contact due to the laws because I couldn’t get information about them, and they couldn’t receive information about me.”

Pooler is member of the Missouri Adoptee Rights Movement, which is seeking to overturn statutes that make it difficult for adoptees to access their family history.

Missouri laws classify adoptions as closed, meaning that when children are adopted here they are not allowed access to their original birth certificates, which list the biological parents.

The law enacted in order to protect the confidentiality of birth parents, but it denies adopted children information about their pasts. And in an age when genetics and healthcare are increasingly linked, that past can be crucial.

Adult adoptees often seek out their unaltered, original birth certificates in order to learn the names of their birth parents. Once in possession of those names, adult adoptees can often research not only their heritage but potentially lifesaving medical history.

Such was the case for Marge Weiderholt and her daughter.

Weiderholt, originally from Stanberry, made the difficult decision to place her first child up for adoption.

“I was not in a place where I was well enough, financially, mentally, or emotionally, to raise a child,” she said, adding that giving up her baby was the hardest thing she has ever had to do.

“Her father had left me, and I was alone,” Weiderholt said. “I wanted her to be well taken care of, and at the time I didn’t believe I was able to do that.”

In October of last year Weiderholt was finally reunited with her daughter, who was suffering from a serious medical condition.

Weiderholt’s daughter and her daughter’s physician had both appealed to the adoption agency that had placed her as a baby to release records that would allow them to find her birth parents and obtain a medical history.

Due to Missouri’s closed adoption laws, the agency refused to release that information.

After that, Weiderholt’s daughter gave up her search. But Weiderholt herself had been searching for her daughter, and with the assistance of a group called Search Angels was able to reunite with her child and provide her with medical information she needed.

“Children who are adopted should be able to have access to their original birth certificates,” Weiderholt said. “They have the right to that information. They have the right to know who their birth parents were, and they have the right to know their birth parents’ medical information at the very least. That’s information that could save a life.”

“No one is saying there has to be a relationship between adoptees and their birth parents,” said adult adoptee Pooler. “If one forms then great, but if not that’s okay too. But we as adoptees have a right to certain information.

“We at least need to know who our birth parents were, and what sort of medical history they have or had. That’s not an outrageous request to make, but according to Missouri law we can’t have that.”

Heather Dodd, founder of the Missouri Adoptee Rights Movement, agrees.

Dodd has been reuniting adopted children and their birth families for nearly 20 years. She also helped Weiderholt find her daughter.

After encountering obstacles when searching for adoptees or birth parents, Dodd founded the Missouri Adoptee Rights Movement.

“Our goal is to help adopted adults regain their right to the information on their original birth certificate,” Dodd said. “There are requests made daily across the state by adoptees for this information, and those requests are denied because of Missouri’s closed adoption laws.”

Weiderholt and Pooler are both members of the Missouri Adoptee Rights Movement and together with Dodd have lobbied legislators in Jefferson City for change.

“We recognize that we have a big battle before us, because this is the way things have been for a long time,” Pooler said. “But adult adoptees do have rights, and we have rights to specific information. Our first goal is for all adult adoptees to have access to their original birth certificates. That would open up so much information for them.

“Our goal is not to make people, like birth parents, uncomfortable or angry. But adult adoptees should be allowed access to information that pertains to them, and that is what we are fighting for.”

Leave a Comment