Skip to content

A mind-reading dog? Yep, his name was Jim

Jason Offutt

Chain restaurants and motels, Wal-Mart, and a John Deere dealership drape the few miles of U.S. 65 that pass through Marshall, Missouri.

This town of about 12,000 was once the home of statesman John Marshall (for whom the town was named), jazz musician Bob James, and Marshall’s former mayor (now deceased) Mitch Geisler, a Kansas police officer during the investigation of the Clutter murders in Truman Capote’s “In Cold Blood.”

But the town’s most famous resident was a dog.

The Chamber of Commerce boasts, “Marshall: Smart Dog, Nice Folks.”

The town was once home to an English Llewellyn Setter named Jim the Wonder Dog —a dog that could read the written word, and as legend claims, could read minds.

There aren’t many people left who remember Jim personally — he died in 1937. But Mary Burge of nearby Arrow Rock remembered Jim.

Mary was a child and part of one of Jim the Wonder Dog’s miracles.

“I had this dress on and a red and white spotted bow,” Mary said.

Her family had come to town that Saturday to shop and had gathered in Marshall’s meeting spot, Sam VanArsdale’s Ruff Hotel.

“Mr. Sam (Jim’s owner) said ‘Jim, go to the girl with the red dress on.’”

The English Llewellyn Setter went to a group of girls standing in the hotel lobby — Mary was one of them — looked at each one and walked back to his owner.

“There were three of us with red dresses,” Mary said. “So (VanArsdale) said ‘go over to the girl with the red and white polka dotted dress.’ Well, there were two of us. He went back and you could tell he didn’t know what to do.”

Then VanArsdale narrowed it down for Jim.

He told him to pick the girl with the polka dotted bow in her hair. The dog walked to Mary. He’d picked the one girl with a bow.

“And (Jim) just gave a sigh to say ‘I’m glad I finally found the girl.’”

Unusual? Not for Jim.

When VanArsdale got the pup in 1925 from a fellow hunter, he hoped Jim would be a good quail-hunting dog.

He was, but when Jim was three, VanArsdale discovered Jim knew a lot more than a dog should.

“To me he was psychic,” said Mildred Conner, president of the Saline County Historical Society. “They don’t want me to say that, but he knew things before they happened.”

During Jim’s life, he picked seven straight Kentucky Derby winners and the winner of the 1936 presidential election.

He could predict the sex of an unborn baby and was able to identify different types of trees, shrubs and cars. He understood commands in English, Spanish, Italian, French, German, shorthand, and Morse code.

“(VanArsdale) said ‘Jim someone’s in here with brown and white shoes’ and Jim went and picked him out,” said Ken Yowell, former executive director of the Marshall Chamber of Commerce and Jim the Wonder Dog buff.

Scientists and veterinarians at the University of Missouri tested Jim and, although Jim had a wider-than-average brow for a setter, the scientists and veterinarians concluded he was just a normal dog — even though he responded to requests in many foreign languages.

During Jim’s life, he was featured in Field and Stream, Missouri Ruralist, Missouri Life Magazine, Ripley’s Believe It or Not, and The Kansas City Star.

Jim died of natural causes March 18, 1937 and was buried near Marshall’s Ridge Park Cemetery.

Jason Offutt’s novel, “A Funeral Story,” is available at amazon.com.

Leave a Comment