Skip to content

Mystery remains in case of slain Northwest co-ed

Alanna Wolf Staff Writer
Tess Hilt

Beautiful. Bubbly. Smart. Kind. Fun.

Those are the words friends used to describe Teresa Sue Hilt — Tess by those who knew her.

A graduate student at Northwest Missouri State University working toward a master of science degree in guidance and counseling, Tess was the kind of girl who seemingly didn’t have an enemy in the world.

And then the unthinkable happened.

Hilt spent the afternoon of Aug. 3, 1973, helping her friend and neighbor in the College Gardens apartment complex, Ed Happel, paint his apartment. Later that evening, the two attended a party, and then returned to Happel’s apartment to watch television.

Around 2 a.m., Hilt decided it was time to return to her own apartment. She told Happel good-bye and walked the 60 feet to her front door.

That was the last time anyone would ever see Hilt alive.

The next day on August 4 Happel repeatedly phoned Hilt to confirm plans the two had made for that evening. When Hilt didn’t answer his calls, Happel became worried. Around 5 p.m. he made his way to Apartment 27 to check on her.

When Happel reached Hilt’s apartment he found the door unlocked. He entered the apartment and made a horrific discovery.

Hilt was facedown on her bed, nude and covered with a sheet. A pair of nylon stockings was wrapped tightly around her neck and she had been stabbed several times.

Tess Hilt had been brutally murdered.

There was no evidence of forced entry to the apartment and later Hilt’s billfold and some unspent traveler’s checks from a recent trip to Colorado were found scattered some distance from her apartment, leading some to wonder if robbery were a motive for her murder.

The murder of the pretty young graduate student sent shockwaves through the Maryville community. Friends and family could think of no logical explanation for her murder.

Hilt, originally from Chillicothe, was involved in campus activities as a member of the Tower yearbook staff, the Student Union board, the marching band, and even college theater productions — she played Peppermint Patty in “You’re a Good Man Charlie Brown”.

“Why would anyone want to kill Tess?” was the oft-asked question in the days following her death.

As police launched their search for Hilt’s killer, numerous leads and theories were investigated.

Happel, who had discovered her body, was initially a “person of interest,” but was quickly cleared by investigators.

Police also investigated the possibility that Hilt may have been involved in a relationship with an older man. She had reportedly told friends that she was in love with an older man, while telling others that she was afraid of an older man. In both instances, Hilt refused to name the older man. Despite searching for the mysterious “older man,” investigators were never able to identify him.

Even considering the brutality of the crime, police didn’t rule out the possibility that a woman could have committed the crime. Investigators reasoned that perhaps female jealousy had played a role in the slaying, but were never able to substantiate that theory.

Other potential suspects included a group of “drifters” who were reportedly seen in Maryville around the time of the murder, and young men Hilt had casually dated, but investigators were unable to pinpoint a specific person of interest.

There was even speculation that Hilt’s master’s thesis may have played a role in her death. She was allegedly working on a paper about drug culture in northwest Missouri, and, according to her mother, had accumulated several pages of notes and research on the topic.

Police searched Hilt’s apartment following her murder and found no evidence of any such paper or research.

Had Hilt uncovered something while writing her alleged thesis?

Would someone have killed Hilt to ensure her silence on what she may have uncovered and then stolen her research?

There seemed to be more questions than answers for investigators.

As the months passed, police continued to search for Hilt’s killer, and following every lead presented to them, even contacting the FBI for assistance. Despite their best efforts at the time, the case remained unsolved and eventually faded into obscurity.

Until 2012, when Hilt’s case was suddenly back in the spotlight through the efforts of her friend, Michall Holmes.

“Tessie Hilt was the first person I met beginning freshman year, 1970, at Northwest Missouri State College,” Holmes recalls. “Tess and I became friends that year; pals really. She was a small girl with a big laugh.”

Through the years, Holmes checked to see if the case were solved and was saddened to discover no killer had ever been found, so he decided to take matters into his own hands. He launched a renewed effort to find Hilt’s killer.

Holmes remembers the beginning of his involvement in the investigation well.

“My wife and I were having lunch at a local Mexican restaurant. We were talking about the fact that retirement was just a few years away,” he said.

“Katy asked, ‘What do you want to do when you retire?’

“Without really thinking, I said, ‘I think I would like to try to find out who murdered an old friend from college,’ and explained the limited details I had about Tess’ case.

“Katy said, slowly and very deliberately, “I don’t think you should wait. I think you should get started.”

Since then, Holmes has created the Teresa Sue “Tess” Hilt Facebook page, a place where people can share memories of Hilt and remain updated on her case, as well as the website http://justicefortess.com which catalogs information from Hilt’s murder investigation and gives people a confidential place to submit tips potentially regarding her murder.

Holmes isn’t alone in his crusade.

Detective Ryan Glidden and Director Keith Wood of Maryville Public Safety continue to search for Hilt’s killer, despite 42 years having passed since the crime.

Even though many originally involved with the case are deceased, Glidden has sorted through witness statements and old police reports. In the last eight months, has traveled to locations in Iowa, Missouri, Nebraska, Kansas, Colorado and Illinois as part of his investigation.

Glidden has spent hours tracking down witness and listening to their stories, many of which are hard to validate as fact, which makes Hilt’s case extremely complicated.

“There’s no documentation, and there are so many stories,” Glidden said. “And they’re not stories that are in official police reports, they’re stories in the community.”

Despite the complications, Glidden still encourages anyone with information regarding Hilt’s case to contact him.

In addition to his extensive efforts, Glidden has received help from outside investigative agencies regarding Hilt’s murder.

He has even investigated the possibility that Hilt’s murder may have been the work of a serial killer, a lead which proved to be inaccurate.

Glidden and Wood are both suspect that Hilt’s murder is the work of a single killer who was more than likely someone Hilt knew, but neither is locked into that opinion and they are willing to investigate all leads.

“If somebody calls here and says, ‘Hey, you need to look at this person, this is what they were doing back then,’ we look into it,” Glidden said. “I’ve called cold case investigators from several states and looked into people.”

A lot has changed in the time since Hilt’s murder. College Gardens is now Horizons West. Many people who knew Hilt have moved from Maryville. All the initial investigators are deceased.

Hilt is not forgotten though. Friends like Michall Holmes, and remaining family members keep her memory alive. Hilt’s mother lives in Chillicothe and prays every day there will be justice for her only child.

“Tess should be a grandmother now. She should have children and grandchildren. She should be here for her friends and for her mom. She should have a beautiful life,” Holmes said.

“The person who killed her has probably gone on to have a family and a life. How unfair it is that they have lived the life Tess should have.

“How unfair that they may have been able to help their own mom when Tess could not be here for hers,” he speculated.

Glidden and Wood have not forgotten either, and both are dedicated to finding justice for Hilt.

The two investigators are grateful for all information that has been submitted regarding Hilt’s case, and they are hopeful that new information will continue to come in, information that could eventually lead to the capture of Hilt’s killer.

A $15,00.00 reward is currently offered for information leading to the arrest and conviction of Hilt’s killer. Anyone with information is encouraged to call Glidden or Wood at 660-562-3209, or email information to [email protected].

Anonymity will be honored if requested.

Leave a Comment