Skip to content

Garbage haulers propose co-op to save transfer station

Headed toward possible closure late next summer, Maryville’s municipal solid waste transfer station received a breath of new life at Monday’s City Council meeting, during which a of group independent garbage haulers proposed forming a cooperative, which would lease the station from the city and operate it as a joint enterprise.

Mike Klosek Jr. of Klosek’s LLC, which provides garbage hauling services to customers in Maryville, Tarkio and Mound City, said that at least four of the garbage companies operating here had expressed interest in joining the co-op and would respond as a single entity to a request-for-proposals that City Manager Greg McDanel said would be issued Sept 1.

Prior to Klosek’s offer, the council appeared to be leaning toward closing the station, which is supposed to be self-supporting but has been losing money since a competing private-enterprise facility was opened in 2012 by Porter Trash LLC.

Klosek said the joint effort proposed by the haulers, each of whom operate in direct competition with the others, is something that has never been tried before. But he added that the mostly family-operated businesses have little choice in the face of what he described as a potential Porter Trash monopoly and the likelihood of higher transfer station tipping fees.

A tipping fee is the per-ton charge imposed by transfer stations for accepting solid waste, which is then compacted and hauled to an approved landfill.

Dennis Porter, who owns Porter Trash, has offered to lock in rates until 2020 that would allow the city to dump street sweepings at his Highway 136 facility for $5 above cost.

Porter has also said he will accept debris from city-demolished unsafe structures for $10 above cost and leave existing rates in place until 2020 for Maryville’s half-dozen or so garbage firms.

Klosek, however, said that with a single transfer station serving the Maryville area, higher tipping fees would be inevitable.

“What it boils down to is monopolization,” he said. “We are willing to take it on, but you need to give us a chance. All I’m asking is that you give us a chance to get our act together.”

McDanel said that due to the city’s existing landfill hauling contract with waste disposal giant Deffenbaugh Industries, it is impractical for Maryville to close its transfer station until Aug., 2016, when the agreement expires.

That leaves enough time, he said, for the city to issue an RFP while giving the haulers’ cooperative 90 days to respond.

However, the request-for-proposals will be publicly advertised, and anyone will be able to submit a bid for leasing the station, not just the co-op. The council is empowered to accept any legitimate offer, or to refuse all of them.

Klosek’s father, Mike Klosek Sr., said the cooperative effort would extend to operating the transfer station only, and that no plans are in place to impose uniform rates for customers or create service zones assigned to each company.

“We’re all competitors, but we’re trying to work together,” the elder Klosek said.

Since Porter opened his facility on Highway 136 east of town, the city’s transfer station has been losing about $100,000 a year.

Aside from closure or the proposed co-op, the only other likely option is municipalization, meaning that the city would contract with a single garbage hauler who would agree to provide town-wide service and use the city’s transfer station exclusively.

Such a move would almost certainly force several existing haulers out of business.

Leave a Comment