Balanced budget requirement may not be good for Congress

Richard Fulton
A push for a balanced budget amendment to the national constitution is once again being pursued by a series of conservative taxpayer groups and their ultra-conservative organization partners.
To be sure, more fiscal responsibility would be refreshing in Washington, but to harness the federal government with the necessity to balance its budget every fiscal year would be irresponsible behavior.
The House of Representatives is taking up a balanced budget amendment this week which would force the federal government to spend only what they raise in any fiscal year. It would include the provision that taxes could only be raised by a two-thirds majority of Congress.
Savings would have to come through cuts.
Only a three-fifth vote of Congress would allow a waiver of the amendment in any fiscal year. How many times has Congress been able to muster a three-fifths vote on any issue in recent years?
Even if conditions were so bad as to need such a vote, what would it do to any long term planning?
Many expenditures of Congress are for multiple years. Note the highway finance bill now lumbering through the corridors of Congress. The amendment would make it impossible to plan more than a year ahead, at best. Many programs are like that.
Many budget items of the feds depend upon reserve funds: the FDIC if banks go under, military pensions, Social Security funding, agriculture support programs. They can only be used if the regular budget is not overextended.
Deficits are used to defray the effects of recessions. If they are not available, the recessions become worse and tip towards depression. The federal government needs flexibility to protect the economy and to maintain its programs in weak economic years.
Republican state legislators are following national lobby organizations in attempting to pass resolutions for a federal balanced budget amendment.
Do they realize that this would devastate their budgets?
Yes, state constitutions all say their governments must balance their budgets. But many of the services they provide are paid for by the federal budget.
Do you think these might be the first to go if the feds have to balance their budget?
Missouri’s total spending budget includes fully one-third of its resources coming from the federal government. No wonder they can balance their budgets.
If the feds have to tighten their budgets, where do you suppose other savings might come from?
How about disaster aid, crop supports, military bases; all of which Missouri depends upon from federal government aid.
The governor just asked for disaster aid from the feds this week. County roads and bridges have been devastated by weather. There go the county budgets if the feds can’t help.
In 1997, another push was made for a balanced budget by conservative Republicans and a few Democrats. One thousand economists, including 11 Nobel laureates, condemned the effort. Last week, five Nobel Prize for Economics winners did the same for the present effort.
It is argued that families and businesses must balance their budgets, but that is hardly true. What are mortgages, car payments, education loans, business loans and bonds but deficit financing.
The amendment before the House wants to cap federal spending at 18 percent of the GDP.
That’s an admirable goal.
But the April budget passed by a Republican Congress spends 20-21 percent of the national GDP. Under its policies, it would take 25 years to reach the 18 percent portal.
And I haven’t mentioned the defense bill that hovers around $612 billion which is half of the discretionary budget of the federal government. A balanced budget would not sustain this level of spending and there go your military bases and war machine businesses Missouri.
