Skip to content

Nodaway County athletes square off in Pony Express League

JASON LAWRENCE/DAILY FORUM
Maryville graduate Jacob Cacek, sliding, attempts to avoid a tag from Northeast Nodaway graduate Andrew Faustlin during a matchup between Cacek’s Grizzlies and Faustlin’s Cobras in Pony Express League action on Monday night at Bartlett Park.

David McGary left the yard twice on Monday night. Once by his own accord on a swift swing, once by the decision of an umpire.

In one of the strangest nights of amateur baseball imaginable, McGary’s game one ejection stoked the flame in a doubleheader between the Cobras and Grizzlies, two Pony Express League teams consisting of Nodaway County players, before his game two dinger effectively put out the fire.

McGary’s Cobras entered the night 6-0, while the Grizzlies, led by coach Richard Allenbrand, sported a 4-0 mark at the beginning of the night. In an eventual split that handed each side its first loss of the summer, mystery ran wild up until the final out of game two.

“It was just intense all the way,” McGary said. “Even being ejected and sitting on the bench, I just couldn’t get more hyped. It was just an awesome game to watch.”

The Cobras — made up Monday night of West Nodaway’s Trevor Meyer; Northeast Nodaway’s Andrew Faustlin, Rowdy West and Garet Jackson; Maryville’s McGary and Alex Catterson; North Nodaway’s Koby Reynolds and Peyton Coleman; and Worth County’s Brevyn Ross — tallied a pair of runs in the opening frame of game one.

Meyer reached on an infield single to open the contest before scoring on a balk call against Grizzlies starter Kade Allenbrand of Maryville. McGary scored later in the frame on a RBI single to right field from Reynolds for a 2-0 lead.

In the top of the second, the Cobras extended their advantage to 4-0 when Jackson scored on a Coleman double before Coleman came around on a RBI from Meyer, who reached on an error.

But in the bottom of the inning, the Grizzlies stormed back with four runs of their own to knot the score. The Grizzlies consisted Monday night of Maryville’s Alex Bean, Keston Oltman, Kade Allenbrand, Jacob Cacek, Jonathan Snook and Garret Sparks; West Nodaway’s Blake Farnan and Treston Sanders; and Nodaway-Holt’s James Chesnut. Cacek and Sparks started the second-inning rally by scoring on wild pitches from Faustlin before Chesnut came home on a single from Bean, who eventually scored on a throwing error from Catterson behind the plate.

Steve Faustlin, head coach for the Cobras, said the camaraderie between the two opponents contributed to some of the wackiness that ensued in the late innings of game one.

“They just weren’t playing like themselves,” he said. “Not buckling down, not focusing. I think there was too much interaction with the other team to start with. Usually, we start off slow the first two innings and pick it up. Tonight, we started off the first two innings and then slowed down.”

The Grizzlies then took a lead of their own in the bottom of the third on back-to-back homers from Farnan and Cacek. Farnan powdered a high, 1-0 fastball from Faustlin to left field before Cacek drilled an outside heater on a rope over the right-center wall at St. Joseph’s Bartlett Park.

Both sides exchanged runs in the fourth inning, the Grizzlies maintaining a 7-5 lead after the frame, when the real chaos began. In the bottom of the fourth, on a RBI groundout from Sanders up the first-base line, McGary bobbled the sharp groundball to allow it to bound into foul territory. As Sanders darted up the line toward the bag, McGary recovered the loose ball and reached for a hard tag on Sanders, warranting an ejection from the home plate umpire.

“I don’t even know what happened there,” McGary said. “I thought I just laid down a kinda hard tag, but it wasn’t like a really full-blown tag.”

Heading into the sixth inning, as the time limit approached, the Cobras required two runs to keep the game alive. Coleman reached on a fielder’s choice and eventually scored on a RBI single from Meyer. With two out and Meyer on first, Faustlin strode to the plate as the second hitter in the lineup with McGary’s spot in the order — an automatic out because of his ejection and no replacement players available — due up next. The Grizzlies chose to intentionally walk Faustlin, which would effectively end the inning.

But as Kade Allenbrand lobbed the first two pitches wide of the strike zone, Meyer easily swiped second and third base. As Allenbrand came set for the third pitch, Meyer bolted for home — Allenbrand stepped off but hesitated before whipping a throw home and Meyer dove headfirst into the plate, dirt leaping into the still air as Meyer beat the throw and tied the game.

“Knowing how Trevor is and the way he plays sports, there’s no one else I would’ve wanted in that position,” Steve Faustlin said. “The only thing I was worried about is his shoulder was hurt, and I was so afraid to have him steal home because I knew if he stole home, he’d dive headfirst. He did, and it worked out.”

The Cobras tallied another run in the top of the seventh, played under extra-inning rules due to the surpassed time limit. But in the bottom of the frame, the Grizzlies came back for a 9-8 win on Sanders coming home on an error charged to Catterson on a wild throw before Bean charged home on what should’ve been a Farnan groundout to first to end the frame — however, miscommunication between West at first base, Coleman at second base and Jackson on the mound allowed Farnan to reach safely and end the game in walk-off fashion.

“A lot (of poise),” Richard Allenbrand said of his team’s finish. “(Kade) pitched well, did a good job. … (Faustlin) was probably their most experienced pitcher at the beginning and we got on him and hit him.”

After a wild game one that left the Cobras with their first loss of the season, Steve Faustlin’s side came back in a big way. They tallied six runs in the first frame and three in the second during game two to take a swift 9-0 lead. Their motivation wasn’t a mystery.

“I think (game one) motivated them a lot more,” Steve Faustlin said. “That was something I wanted to see, because if they want to go to the Show-Me State Games in about three weeks, they need to bounce back from games like that.”

The Grizzlies tallied their only run of the second contest in the top of the fourth when Bean singled, stole second, advanced to third on a hit and came home on an error.

In the bottom of the fourth, with the 10-run spread after five innings looming, the Cobras came up with four runs before shutting down the Grizzlies in the top of the fifth, ending the contest at 13-1.

But three of those final four runs came on the back of the player who was relegated to the bench for the last three innings of game one: a motivated McGary. With one run already home and two runners lurking on the basepaths, McGary walloped a grooved pitch from Cacek into the trees beyond left field, making up for missed time in the opening stage of the twin bill.

“During practice, I’ve been trying so hard to get that swing down and everything,” said McGary, who couldn’t resist taking a jab at his fellow 2015 Spoofhound graduate. “It finally just pulled through. I got a good hit on it, I guess. Saw it all the way down and I couldn’t ask for a better pitch (to hit.) I’ve got to give props to Jacob Cacek for it.”

Following the split, the Grizzlies are 5-1 while the Cobras stand at 7-1. A strange night at the ballpark, with oddity multiplied by players competing against schoolmates and former teammates, turned out just fine for everyone involved.

“It’s fun,” Richard Allenbrand said. “They joke around with each other, so it’s always fun, it’s always fun playing them. Actually, I’ve used two or three of (the Cobras) players to play in weekend tournaments, so they know each other well. It’s a good time. Good, fun competition.”

JASON LAWRENCE/DAILY FORUM
David McGary, a 2015 graduate from Maryville and player for the Pony Express League’s Cobras, takes a hack at a pitch during game two of a doubleheader against the Grizzlies. McGary was ejected in game one for a hard tag before bouncing back with a three-run homer in game two.

JASON LAWRENCE/DAILY FORUM
Nodaway County baseball players, including Maryville’s Kade Allenbrand, took aim at one another Monday night during a matchup between the Grizzlies and Cobras in the Pony Express League. The two teams comprised almost exclusively of Nodaway County athletes split their doubleheader.

JASON LAWRENCE/DAILY FORUM
North Nodaway junior Peyton Coleman rockets a double into right-center during the second inning of Monday’s first contest between the Cobras and Grizzlies at Bartlett Park.

JASON LAWRENCE/DAILY FORUM
During Monday night’s Pony Express League doubleheader between the Cobras and Grizzlies at Bartlett Park, West Nodaway senior Blake Farnan takes a clean rip. Farnan tallied a home run in the first game of the twin bill.

JASON LAWRENCE/DAILY FORUM
Northeast Nodaway graduate Andrew Faustlin whistles a pitch toward the plate on Monday night at Bartlett Park during the Cobras two-game split against the Grizzlies.

JASON LAWRENCE/DAILY FORUM
Spoofhound junior Alex Bean charges a groundball and tosses to first base on Monday night as the Grizzlies split a doubleheader with the Cobras in Pony Express League play.

JASON LAWRENCE/DAILY FORUM
Koby Reynolds, entering his senior year at North Nodaway, takes a hack for the Cobras during the first game of Monday’s doubleheader against the Grizzlies at Bartlett Park in St. Joseph.

JASON LAWRENCE/DAILY FORUM
Austin Jones, a 2015 Northeast Nodaway graduate, knocks a high fastball back up the middle for a single Monday night at Bartlett Park during the Cobras’ doubleheader against the Grizzlies.

Leave a Comment