Ethics Reform and Reigning in Tax Credits Remain Unfinished Business

Dan Hegeman
There were many times during the 2015 legislative session my colleagues and I worked together to bring reform to government or bring resolution to some of the important challenges facing our state. Unfortunately, I’m disappointed to say that progress did not extend to two areas I believe are in desperate need of reform: ethics and tax credits.
Over the last several years there has been much discussion by the General Assembly on these two issues, but the final results have all been the same. Whether through disagreements between individual provisions, personality conflicts, or last minute opposition that cannot be overcome, these reforms seem to start strong and die with a whimper.
This year’s ethics reforms were once again centered on implementation of a “cooling-off” period that would prohibit legislators from becoming lobbyists immediately upon leaving office and various measures concerning conduct between lobbyists and legislators. These reforms were simple common-sense measures that would bring greater integrity and accountability to the legislative process. Yet, while these reforms received strong support early in the process, once again an agreement could not be reached and the bill failed to reach the Governor.
But, while there was at least progress on the discussion of ethics reforms, I was most disappointed by the lack of progress regarding the reform of Missouri’s largest tax credit programs. The Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) Program and the Missouri Historic Preservation Tax Credit (HPTC) Program are massive programs that cost the state hundreds of millions of dollars every year. While these programs have laudable goals, their lack of efficiency and poor return to the taxpayer demands reform.
According to a report from the state auditor’s office on the LIHTC and HPTC programs, For Fiscal Year 2013, they found that only 49 cents to 85 cents of every tax credit dollar issued under the HPTC program actually went toward rehabilitation costs; the remainder went to investors, tax credit brokers and the federal and state government in the form of income taxes. The auditor’s report for the LIHTC, the state’s single largest tax credit program, revealed that in FY 2013 the program returned a dismal $0.08 in state revenue for every dollar spent and created approximately 63 new full-time jobs. In other words, with FY 2013 redemptions of $144 million, the program cost taxpayers approximately $61,000 per unit of housing or $2.3 million per job.
The lack of reform in these two areas has certainly been frustrating
to me as it must be to voters and
taxpayers. But, while we were unable to reach agreement on reform-
ing these issues, the discussion and the effort towards reform will not stop. I expect for there to be continued discussions towards ethics and tax credit reforms and I am hopeful that these issues will not be considered unfinished business at the end
of the 2016 Legislative Session.
