Skip to content

Wake up, Royals fans, it’s all just a dream

Phil Cobb

It’s every Kansas City Royals fan’s dream come true.

Identify the weakest players on the Royals roster and replace them with the best players in the American League.

You’re not happy with the play of second baseman Omar Infante?

Fine.

How about Houston’s Jose Altuve?

Alex Rios hasn’t done much since he came back from injury?

Get him out of there.

Replace him in right field with Lorenzo Cain and put Mike Trout and his 16 homeruns in center field.

The starting pitching hasn’t satisfied your expectations? Let’s replace them with a quintet of sub-2.50 ERA guys.

How would Chris Archer, with his 108 strikeouts, seven wins and 1.64 ERA look at the top of the rotation?

Believe it or not, we might get to find out.

Through midweek, the Kansas City Royals were in position to have seven of the nine offensive starters in the MLB All-Star Game.

Catcher Salvador Perez leads all vote-getters, with more than 4.4 million.

Six other Royals lead the voting at their respective positions, including Mike Moustakas at third, Eric Hosmer at first, Cain and Alex Gordon in the outfield, Alcides Escobar at shortstop and Kendrys Morales as the designated hitter.

So, with the exception of Trout and Altuve, the rest of the team is made up of Royals.

Even the manager and the coaching staff will be Royals, thanks to the team’s World Series appearance last season.

The position players are picked by the fans.

The pitchers are picked by the managers.

You’d have to think at least a couple of Kansas City’s bullpen guys would be picked.

Kelvin Herrera? Wade Davis? Greg Holland? HDH?

It’s hard to argue against any one of that trio.

So, what to make of the blue washing of the American League roster for the Midsummer Classic?

I don’t like it.

What?

Wait.

Look. You all know I have an irrational love affair with the Royals.

But even I can see that this won’t end well.

What’s the worst that can happen?

Let’s look back to 1957.

Fans in Cincinnati stuffed the ballot boxes to get seven of their starters in that season’s All-Star Game.

More than half of the total ballots that year were cast in Cincinnati.

The Cincinnati Enquirer printed extra ballots and distributed them in their Sunday edition.

Major League Baseball didn’t stand for it.

Commissioner Ford Frick stepped in and appointed Willie Mays and Hank Aaron to start the game in place of two of the Redlegs.

And for the next 12 seasons, the fans had no say in the selection of players for the game.

The 2015 season marks the first time the fan portion of the voting has been done entirely online.

Kansas City’s fans are stuffing the virtual ballot box.

And I don’t suspect MLB will stand for it.

If newly-elected commissioner Rob Manfred doesn’t step in this year, he certainly will prior to next season’s voting process.

As much as I would like to see all my favorite Royals players in the All-Star Game, and as much as I’d like to be able to justify what is happening, I just can’t.

The stats don’t back them up.

Hosmer seems like a good choice at first base until you think about perennial MVP candidate Miguel Cabrera, who has five more homeruns, four more RBI and whose batting average is 29 points higher.

Again, defense has to factor in, so an argument can be made for Hosmer, who is probably the best defensive first-bagger currently in the big leagues.

Escobar will not disappoint at shortstop, but three other American League shortstops are having better years, including Xander Bogaerts of Boston, Marcus Semien of Oakland and Erick Aybar of Los Angeles.

Again, Escobar is probably the best defender of the bunch.

Morales seems like a good pick at DH. He’s been a great addition to the Royals.

But Texas Rangers DH Prince Fielder has three more homers, the same amount of RBI and is batting 62 points higher.

I think you can make a case for each one of the Royals individually, especially when defense is factored in (minus Morales, of course).

But I can’t make an argument for the entire group.

If the Royals would have continued the pace they set through the first six weeks of the season, things might be different, but they hit some kind of a snag about half way through May and they just haven’t been the same since.

Is it going to hurt anything if the American League team is made up mostly of Royals?

No.

The National League is going to have a heck of a time putting runs on the board.

Is it bad for baseball?

Probably not.

But is it what the spirit of the All-Star Game is all about?

I don’t think so.

Sorry, Royals fans, this is all just a dream.

Leave a Comment