Pace of play in baseball: How much is too much?

Phil Cobb
I’m all for reducing the amount of time it takes to complete a nine-inning Major League Baseball game, especially one between the likes of the Boston Red Sox and the New York Yankees, which routinely exceeds three hours in length.
But let’s not get so carried away that we change what the game is intended to be, or has always been — America’s national pastime.
With the advent of replay in 2014, the game, as was expected, slowed down a bit, as umpires and managers fumbled through the initial stages of the process.
The amount of time to get the call right did improve somewhat by the end of the season, but there is certainly room for more advancement in that area.
Why can’t the umpiring crew in New York, which sees every play, buzz the umps on the field when there is a call that requires review?
Do we want to get all the calls right or just the ones the opposing managers think they can successfully have reversed?
This song-and-dance between the managers, their review specialists and the umps on the field is embarrassing for all involved, besides being a major drag on the game clock.
Now officials have introduced what they refer to as “pace of game initiatives.”
I’m not a big fan of what amounts to the baseball equivalent of basketball’s shot clock between innings and following pitching changes.
I don’t think this does much of anything to solve the overall problem.
My feeling is that if you want to speed up the pace of the game, force the umpires to call the strike zone as it is defined in the rulebook.
The definition of the strike zone has changed fairly dramatically since the middle of the 20th century, but not nearly as much as it’s interpretation.
According to mlb.com, as of 1950, “The Strike Zone is that space over home plate which is between the batter’s armpits and the top of his knees when he assumes his natural stance.”
In 1963, the upper extent of the strike zone was actually raised from the armpits to the top of the shoulders.
In 1969 it was changed back to armpits.
That version remained intact for almost 20 years, until 1988, when things started getting more complicated and left more room for an umpire’s interpretation.
Here’s how the strike zone was defined almost 30 years ago: “The Strike Zone is that area over home plate, the upper limit of which is a horizontal line at the midpoint between the top of the shoulders and the top of the uniform pants, and the lower level is a line at the top of the knees. The Strike Zone shall be determined from the batter’s stance as the batter is prepared to swing at a pitched ball.”
So basically, from the numbers to the knees.
In 1996, that version was expanded on the lower end, moving from the top of the knees to the bottom of the knees.
The definition has not changed since.
So why is it that the typical major league strike zone today appears to be that area over the plate which includes an area from the ankles to the belt?
Force the umpires to call the real strike zone and we’ll see a lot more balls in play, as batters will be forced to swing at pitches they are currently “spitting on.”
Really, this would solve two major problems the league is facing — a steady decrease in offense and a steady increase in the length of games.
Everybody wins.
But let’s not tinker with what makes baseball baseball.
Much of a pitcher’s effectiveness has to do with interrupting the routine of the batter and vice versa, the batter can gain advantage from throwing off the pace of the pitcher.
These are important nuances of the game.
There are other unnecessary rituals that are annoying and add nothing to the strategy or enjoyment of the game — readjusting one’s batting gloves between pitches certainly should be addressed.
According to Atlanta Braves president and former Kansas City Royals General Manager John Schuerholz, who is the chairman of the Pace of Play and Instant Replay committee, “The Pace of Game Committee wants to take measured steps as we address this industry goal to quicken the pace of our great game. It is not an objective of ours to achieve a dramatic time reduction right away; it is more important to develop a culture of better habits and a structure with more exact timings for non-game action.”
That seems like the right approach.
I just hope it doesn’t turn into something else.
Let’s let baseball be baseball and don’t try to make it into a streamlined version of itself.
