Skip to content

Appeals court to convene on NW campus

KANSAS CITY, Mo. — The Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District, will convene on the campus of Northwest Missouri State University at 1 p.m. Monday, March 16, when a three-judge panel consisting of Western District judges Gary Witt and James Welsh and Missouri Supreme Court Judge Zel Fischer is to hear oral arguments in two cases in the J.W. Jones Student Union.

The court’s chief judge, Alok Ahuja, said the cases are appeals from area circuit courts, and that the panel will hear attorneys argue whether the trials contained errors that should cause them to be reheard or reversed.

All three judges will remain after the court session in order to discuss the workings of Missouri Court of Appeals and answer questions from the public.

The open session will mark the sixth time the Western District court has convened at Northwest since 2010.

One of two cases to be considered during the Maryville session is an appeal related to a campus traffic stop by a Northwest Missouri State police officer in Sept., 2013.

According to court records, Officer Travis Cochenour pulled over a vehicle driven by Lucas D. Jewell, who allegedly failed to stop at two different stop signs.

The signs, court documents state, were maintained by the university and were not placed by state or city authorities.

After Jewell was charged with misdemeanor driving while intoxicated and failure to stop, he filed motions to suppress evidence and dismiss the case, claiming the officer did not have probable cause to pull him over.

The trial court sustained Jewell’s motions, finding that probable cause for the stop was improper since campus streets are not state highways or roadways.

As the appellant, the state of Missouri alleges the trial court erred, and that campus traffic regulations carry the same force as municipal law.

The second appeal involves the conviction on a felony drug possession charge of William L. Boling, who was arrested in Andrew County after California Department of Justice Agent Ryan Maki attached a GPS device to Boling’s vehicle in that state.

When Boling was involved in an accident on Interstate 29, Maki advised Missouri authorities that the vehicle possibly contained several pounds of marijuana.

Boling appealed his conviction, and is arguing that authorities both conducted an improper search of the vehicle and lacked probable cause to obtain a search warrant.

Witt will preside during the court’s session at Northwest Missouri State. He was appointed to the court in 2010 and previously served as an associate circuit judge in Platte County. Earlier in his career, Witt practiced law in Platte County and served in the Missouri House of Representatives.

Welsh was appointed to the Western District Court of Appeals in 2007 and served as the court’s chief judge in 2013-2014. He previously practiced law for ten years before serving successively as a municipal judge, associate circuit judge and circuit judge in Clay County.

Fischer, a native of Rockport, was appointed to the Missouri Supreme Court in 2008. Before joining the state’s high court, he was an associate circuit judge for Atchison County and practiced law in Atchison, Holt, Nodaway and Platte counties.

“It is important for the Court to convene oral arguments outside of Kansas City,” Witt said. “This gives individuals an opportunity to observe a part of the judicial system they normally do not see. We hope those attending will gain a better understanding of the Court’s function.”

Over the past 23 years, the court has also convened in the cities of Chillicothe, Columbia, Fulton, Gallatin, Huntsville, Independence, Jefferson City, Keytesville, Kirksville, Lake Ozark, Lexington, Liberty, Linneus, Macon, Marshall, Milan, Nevada, Platte City, Richmond, Rockport, St. Joseph, Savannah, Trenton, Tuscumbia and Warrensburg.

The Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District, hears cases from trial courts in 45 northwestern and central Missouri counties and normally convenes in Kansas City.

Leave a Comment