Skip to content

Lawsuit gives details of couple’s arrest

Nodaway County Sheriff Darren White has received a copy of the lawsuit filed against him and Sheriff’s Capt. David Glidden by a former Maryville couple who say the officers violated their Fourth Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment rights under the U.S. Constitution by improperly entering their home and placing their children in protective custody.

The suit was filed in November in federal District Court by Jason and Laura Hagan. Now residents of New Hampton in Harrison County, the Hagans also claim to be acting “as parents and next friends” of their three minor children.

The Hagans are reportedly being represented by the Home School Legal Defense Association, a nonprofit advocacy group with the stated goal of advancing “the constitutional right of parents to direct the education of their children and to protect family freedoms.”

According to the suit, on Sept. 30, 2011, Glidden and White “forcefully entered the home of Jason and Laura Hagan, without consent or order.”

The court filing further alleges the “officers pepper-sprayed Jason, Laura, and their dog, and Glidden shot Jason with a Taser.”

After the suit was filed, but before he had seen a copy of the court documents, White said Glidden went to the house in response to a message from the Missouri Department of Social Services concerning allegations that the Hagan children were living in squalor.

According to the lawsuit, Glidden arrived at the residence and encountered Laura Hagan on the front porch, at which point Jason Hagan, who was reportedly inside the home, telephoned the HSLDA to seek advice on how to respond to the deputy’s request to enter.

Laura Hagan reportedly re-entered the house at which point Jason Hagan came to the door and told Glidden he could not come inside unless he displayed a warrant or court order.

There was a struggle, and White arrived at the scene. According to the lawsuit Glidden incapacitated Jason Hagan with a Taser. In addition, HSLDA claims, both Hagans were shot with pepper spray, as was their dog.

After being subdued, the Hagans were handcuffed and taken to the Nodaway County jail. All three children were placed in protective custody.

The lawsuit confirms that the Sheriff’s Department was called in by a social worker from the Missouri Department of Social Services who had visited the home several days earlier and returned on the day of the Sept. 30 incident.

The suit also states the children were returned to their parents nine days later on a “temporary home placement,” and that the Hagans’ legal custody was restored on March 21, 2012.

During the intervening five months, the suit claims, the Hagans were required to report to a social worker “whenever seeking medical care for the children.”

Criminal charges against the Hagans were subsequently dropped, and the suit quotes a Circuit Court finding to suppress evidence in the case.

A portion of that decision reads: “It is not plausible to believe the condition of the premises would change or that the risk to any child in the residence would be any greater during the delay necessary to obtain a warrant. No exigent circumstances existed, no matter how filthy or disgusting the premises appeared or smelled from the doorway.”

In filing the suit, the Hagans claimed the episode caused them “mental pain and suffering; emotional distress; and loss of enjoyment of life.

Causes of action listed in the suit allege White and Glidden violated the couple’s Fourth Amendment right to be free from unreasonable search and seizure as well as the Fourteenth Amendment clause that bars authorities from depriving citizens of “life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.”

The Hagans are seeking unspecified compensatory and punitive damages plus attorney fees.

White said he has referred the lawsuit to the county’s insurer, the Missouri Public Entity Risk Management Fund.

Leave a Comment