Skip to content

Two heads better than one for North-West Nodaway

STEVE HARTMAN/DAILY FORUM
Scott Reeves, left, and Andrew Webster, right, oversee a North-West Nodaway football walk-through during the 2014 football season. The two coaches overcame many obstacles in combining their programs to form a very successful football coop.

Scott Reeves can still remember the first time he heard about the idea of “co-oping” West Nodaway’s football program with North Nodaway.

“We were on our way to St. Joe last March, going to watch the first-round state basketball games,” Reeves, the former West Nodaway head football coach said. “Roger Johnson, our athletic director, asked me how I would feel about co-oping with North Nodaway. That was the first time I’d heard that idea.

“Andrew (Webster) called the next week to get my thoughts about the possibility of co-oping with them. I didn’t have the heart to tell him the deadline had passed for filing the paperwork with MSHSAA for co-oping. I did tell him I would consider it.”

Reeves continued summer weight training and summer camps with his West Nodaway Rockets, but watched the team numbers dwindle as the summer wore on.

By July, those numbers were down to 10 or 11 players, and that prompted Reeves to have a discussion with West Nodaway Superintendent Nancy Greeley.

“I told Nancy we could play our schedule with 10 or 11 kids,” Reeves said. “But it would be far from ideal. The kids would not get a break during games and could be more susceptible to injury. That wasn’t what either of us wanted.”

After both West Nodaway and North Nodaway administrators and school boards had met and discussed the matter of co-oping the program, Reeves and North Nodaway head coach Andrew Webster were notified August 4 that the teams would be combined once the plan received emergency approval from MSHSAA.

“We had a ‘trial’ practice together that night,” North-West Nodaway head coach Andrew Webster said. “It didn’t give Scott (Reeves) and I a lot of time to get things organized and make decisions, but we did the best we could.”

The first decision to be made was the designation of coaching duties, and both Webster and Reeves were used to the title and responsibilities of the head coaching position, and only one could carry that title through this co-oping venture for both schools.

Webster, originally from Dexter, Mo., had been a head coach at Tarkio for three seasons prior to coming to North Nodaway, where 2014 was to be his second year as head coach. Reeves, a native of Willard, Mo., had been both a head coach and assistant coach in his career, which includes stops at Stockton, Pleasant Hope, Lee’s Summit and Lockwood.

“I’ve been a head coach since my career started,” Webster said. “I wanted to keep the title because I have a character education program that I implement and believe strongly in, and I thought being an assistant coach would make implementing that program more difficult.”

Reeves had two requirements he wanted out of the co-op arrangement, and if both could be achieved with him being an assistant, or co-head coach, he had few problems with a change in title.

“I wanted to continue the work I had started with the West Nodaway kids,” Reeves said. “I also wanted to keep implementing this offense. I look at defense, but I really don’t want to think about defense, especially as hard as it is in 8-man football. I wanted to focus on this offense and what it could do.”

The two head coaches agreed that Webster would have the title of head coach, and focus on defense, while Reeves would have the title of associate head coach and be in charge of offense.

Reeves decided to work from the press box, and to enhance game-day communication between all the coaches, new high-end head sets were purchased.

Alan Calfee, who served as an assistant to Reeves at West Nodaway, took care of signaling in offensive plays after getting them from Reeves via head set. David DeBuhr, who worked as an assistant coach under Webster at North Nodaway the year before, assisted Webster with the defense. Assistants Kolton Jones and Michael Trautz helped out wherever necessary.

“Our assistants did a great job all season,” Webster said. “It took awhile to get everyone settled in to their duties.”

Adding to the difficulty in combining the two programs into one was the fact that the two schools were great rivals, and had been for several years. Plus, the one time the two coaches met on opposite sidelines, emotions ran high.

“When we played them last year, I just thought a lot of things got out of hand,” Webster said. “I didn’t care much for Scott that night, and I’m sure he would say the same about me. Scott’s an orange, and I’m an apple. We’re just different people.”

Reeves echoed Webster’s sentiment of that evening. “We’re both fiercely competitive, and that night, we really didn’t care much for one another in the heat of battle.”

However, both maintained professional civility with one another in the offseason, which made the transition to one program easier. The two have learned to turn their differences as people into a positive.

“Scott is more of a ‘say whatever is on his mind’ kind of person,” Webster said. “At times, he gets me fired up when I need to be. I try to be more of a ‘think about my response’ person, and at times I have calmed him down. We have learned to balance one another’s personalities with our own.”

When the decision was made to combine the two programs, Webster decided to draw his entire offensive playbook on the white board in his office, as a sign to Reeves that he was all-in and holding nothing back.

“I told Coach Webster that if I couldn’t trust him, we had a problem,” Reeves said. “But he showed me his whole playbook, had me over to his house to meet his family and cook me a steak, and earned my trust.”

The players adjusted to the combined program quickly, both coaches said.

“We had a few who probably didn’t play because of the co-op,” Webster said. “But for most of them, once they practiced together, they saw that Coach Reeves and I were unified in what we wanted to do, and they saw the possibilities of what we could accomplish together, they were committed.”

The schedule did the fledgling program no favors either, as only 18 days after that first combined practice, a road game with defending state runner-up Stanberry loomed.

North-West lost the opening contest to Stanberry, 56-38, but the game showed both players and coaches the possibilities of what the team could accomplish with more experience.

“I was excited after that first game,” Webster said. “I had no idea what to expect, and all things considered, we played pretty well.”

Sitting at 2-2 on the season, North-West traveled to Grant City to take on Worth County in week five, and both coaches agreed this was the game where things started to mold to their liking.

“The Worth County game in week five was really the game where everything began to jell,” Webster said. “Everyone, both players and coaches, really seemed to start to get comfortable in their roles that night.”

North-West downed Worth County, 70-46, that night, and started the team on a streak of six wins in seven games, which included a 60-14 District 1 championship victory over Rock Port, a team that beat North-West 34-18 in week two.

Although the North-West season came to a halt with an 86-30 loss to Stanberry in the 8-man state semifinals, making their final record 8-4, the season was more successful than either school could have produced on it’s own.

“We likely would have won two or three games on our own,” Webster said.

Reeves agreed, saying, “We would have won a couple if we could have played all of our games. With our numbers, we were one or two injuries from cancelling the remainder of the season.”

Both coaches agree that now that the first season of combining programs is over, the process will get easier and the program will get stronger.

“We only lose two players, Trevor (Meyer) and Ty (Cowan),” Webster said. “While they are both great players and great kids and can’t be replaced, we will have freshmen ready to step in. Plus, having a year of successful experience for players like Jakob Cordell, Koby Reynolds, Dakota Smyser and Blake Farnan will make a huge difference for those guys, and all the players who played this season. Developing a culture of success is very important.”

For his part, Reeves is excited about working with Webster in the offseason and combining many of the offseason activities, like weight lifting contests, with both groups of players.

“We will continue what we always do in the offseason,” Reeves said. “But now, we will do a lot of the weekend lifting contests with coach Webster and the kids from North Nodaway.”

Both coaches expressed excitement about having one set of uniforms, and a common mascot, although practice and game locations will continue to be alternated between the two schools.

“The first year was bound to be tough,” Webster said. “Both schools were rivals, and we didn’t have a lot of time to think about the best way to do everything. Now that we’ve done it once, kids coming into the program will be more acclimated to it, because that’s just the way the program works.”

As far as the two head coaches and where their relationship stands, each has a telling quote that indicates that the two will continue to grow as coaching partners and friends.

“I have the best football job in northwest Missouri,” Reeves said. “Andrew is the face of the program on the sideline every Friday night, while I get to sit up in the press box where I can see everything and call plays.”

Webster has grown to trust Reeves with two of the most valuable “players” in his life.

“Scott is my kids’ favorite babysitter,” Webster said. “I really enjoy his friendship and coaching with him.”

Leave a Comment