Tenure — an unjust umbrella or teacher contract protectio

Matt Pearl
I suppose I knew that there were a handful of folks in state government, as well as a few interest groups here and there, who seem determined to destroy Missouri’s public education system.
The most efficient way to cause upheaval in public ed., of course, is to go after teachers. That appears to be the purpose of the measure that will be known as Amendment 3 on our November ballots in the Show-Me State.
True to form, the proponents of this amendment are lashing out at teacher tenure, claiming that student performance on standardized tests and other measurable data should be at least 50 percent of the criteria that would be used to determine whether teachers would be deemed worthy to keep their jobs.
To an extent, student performance should be part of the measuring stick used to evaluate educators. But the inherent danger of such a practice is what has teachers nervous.
For nine months a year, five days a week, teachers have their direct influence over the lives of their students. For a high school teacher, it’s about 45-50 minutes per day with a given student; that’s a bit over 130 hours a year.
So we have established that a high school math teacher, as an example, has class with a given student for less than one and a half percent of the student’s life during a calendar year. But 100 percent of the teacher’s job depends upon that student’s performance in the classroom.
Imagine if parents were under that kind of pressure. Could you fathom what would happen if mom and dad could be threatened with loss of income or property if their children didn’t perform up to par academically?
You can’t even dream it, because it would never happen. Parent worthiness doesn’t seem to be as measurable as teacher accountability.
The amendment would also call for a new evaluation system to be adopted by the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education for the measuring of teacher effectiveness.
Those of you who are around education know that this is happening anyway, and the new evaluation system (which has also gone through a round of bureaucratic rejection) is about as easy to understand as an instruction manual to the space shuttle, written in another language.
Amendment 3 is receiving financial and promotional backing from a group called Teach Great. They claim their goals include promoting better pay for good teachers, while eliminating tenure and pushing out the bad ones.
That’s the arrow they’re pointing, perhaps with noble cause, but it’s not the target they will hit. The tenure-eliminating agenda would take effect first, I fear, and the better pay might never come in the form they advertise. Then what would public education face?
They would be trying to hire teachers to a profession with no hope of tenure for the same money teachers are making now with tenure. It’s cutting a benefit and expecting to hire better employees because of it. That’s lacking in logic to me.
The problem lies in how you choose to view teacher tenure: Do you see it as an unjust umbrella to protect incompetent teachers, or as contract protection for our underpaid professionals?
Matt Pearl teaches in the King City R-I school district.
