Skip to content

There are obviously situations when it’s clear, crime does pay

Richard Fulton

This week’s edition of The Economist, a conservative British news weekly, is headlined by a cover story entitled “The Criminalization of American Business.” It’s thesis is that “Corporate America is finding it harder to stay on the right side of the law.”

The criminal acts of corporations are found not only in the largely publicized cases of financial institutions, but also through fines and regulatory restrictions in a wide variety of areas like environmental cases (BP’s toxic pollution of the Gulf) and national security breeches.

In this latter category is the recent criminal settlement with the U.S. by the French banking giant BNP. They agreed to a nearly $9 billion fine for violating economic sanctions against Iran, Sudan and Cuba.

Large legal settlements by large corporations seem to hit the news every week.

Bank of America has agreed to a settlement for selling “toxic mortgage securities” that set a new record fine of $16.65 billion dollars. The list of financial institutions fined and/or limited in their activities in the U.S. is full of the world’s largest financial businesses.

Goldman Sachs ($1.2 billion) and Standard Charters ($300 million) are examples just from this August. Others this year include Credit Suisse, Morgan Stanley, Citigroup, Barclays Bank, and Bank of America in yet another case.

Toyota, General Electric, General Motors, and the Hospital Corporation of America represent some of the non-financial corporations caught by the federal government.

The Economist notes research from Brandon Garrett, a law professor, that found “2,163 corporate convictions and guilty pleas” since 2000.

Fines and convictions have increased during this period as well.

The article hastens to say that prosecutors have increasingly been secretive about the processes and specifics of the settlements with corporations. Some of the agreements, for example, indicate as part of the settlement that the corporations cannot take the fines off their income taxes.

Yet, headlines on the Bank of America’s nearly $7 billion settlement indicate that there was no such limit to the agreement. The bank can claim from $10 to $11.63 billion as deductions on its tax returns.

Too often, the corporations simply see getting caught and paying fines as part of the cost of doing business. Their profits continue to be huge anyway.

This culture of crime continues because nobody is criminally charged for their actions.

Indeed, those responsible often are those given large pay increases.

How do they get away with this?

They have lobbyists who set the stage for their actions. Laws setting oversight of financial institutions, for example, were gutted in the decade prior to the 2008 collapse.

Research by Martin Giles of Princeton University and Benjamin Page of Northwestern used statistical analysis to study influence on legislation in the United States. As reported in another The Economist article last May, the two concluded: “Not only do ordinary citizens not have uniquely substantial power over policy decisions: they have little or no independent influence on policy at all.”

If there were low support for a policy amongst the wealthy, they report, only 18 percent of the time were the policies passed. If four or five wealthy supported a policy, the success rate went to 45 c. Let’s hear it for the Koch brothers.

Support by majorities, or even tiny minorities, of average income people found a success rate closer to 30 percent.

Why is there an increased culture of criminalization within American business?

Because it pays, with little chance of individuals being held criminally responsible.

Leave a Comment