Geekology 101: Thor gets a makeover?

Beta Ray Gary
You know, I don’t have a problem with messing with a comic book character, as long as it is done properly.
So when I heard that Marvel was taking a long-standing character, a character important to its movie franchises, and flipping things around, I was intrigued.
Then I found out what they were doing and I was a little less intrigued.
They are making Thor into a woman?
Now I don’t have a problem with the idea of Marvel making a push on strong female characters.
I would like to stand up and cheer them for that.
But Thor?
Making Thor a woman?
Really?
Okay, so Thor at times has been a frog, a Korbinite, and even Eric Masterson.
So why would his becoming a woman be such a bad idea?
For me, I think taking a long-standing character and doing something radical — like killing, doing drugs, switching bodies, dying, and even allowing Joel Schumacher to direct a movie about them — is always a bad idea.
Remember the big “let’s change their uniforms” debacle in the 90s?
Why not, Marvel Comics, take a woman character, that they have had in their stable for a long time, and give that character a big push?
If you don’t know any, well that is because Marvel typically doesn’t do that.
Most of the times a woman lead is featured as part of a team.
Take Invisible Woman, Rogue, Scarlet Witch, Wasp, Jean Grey, etc., etc., and they have all been a part of a superhero group such as the Avengers, Fantastic Four, and the X-Men at one time or another.
Oh they have tried with the She-Hulk series that keeps getting cancelled and then restarted.
There was even a great story involving a fallen hero named Jessica Jones, but it only ran for 28 issues.
Then there was Carol Danvers as Ms. Marvel who would get pushed out of her own series and into the Guardians of the Galaxy.
Personally, I think taking a dynamic character such as Wasp or Rogue and putting good talent behind the project would be more interesting that Thor as a woman.
It is sad that they have to result to some kind of publicity stunt to get more female readers to notice their product.
Or maybe they are just jealous of the push that Wonder Woman is getting about having her own movie.
Maybe they don’t think that Black Widow will be able to compete in a head-to-head competition with the Amazon Princess.
So let’s take Thor and make him into a woman.
Then, when Chris Hemsworth gets bored of the role, we can use the new woman Thor in the movie universe!
Great idea?
I don’t know.
I love the idea of a woman character that young girls can relate to in the comic book world.
I can’t wait for my own daughter to find that character that she will eventually grow attached to.
But not some gimmick!
I don’t like gimmicks.
Give me a well done fleshed out character that doesn’t rely on shock and awe to get attention.
How about taking a character that has a great history, throw your best artists and writers onto the project, and give that character as big a push as you are giving the woman Thor.
You may just be surprised at the results.
