‘Hobby Lobby’ decision is fair

Matt Pearl
Christians everywhere are celebrating the landmark “Hobby Lobby” case in the U.S. Supreme Court as a great victory for the cause of their faith, as well as for traditional views of medical issues.
If you’re one of them, I hate to be the doom-and-gloom bearer, but this court has no particular interest in protecting Christianity. But it did its job, nonetheless.
By protecting Hobby Lobby’s right not to insure for medical devices and/or procedures with which the craft store giant has a moral objection, the court was trying to uphold the First Amendment rights of Hobby Lobby and others.
Understand that this decision was a 5-4 split likely because of the precedent it sets. A friend of mine who opposed the ruling noted her fear that the decision put corporations on equal footing with private citizens, capable of making decisions that affect employee insurance and medical coverage based upon moral principles.
The problem with that: Now corporations have the legal precedent (and a strong one — a Supreme Court ruling) to deny certain coverages that Obamacare would otherwise have required them to offer to their employees.
That very well may cause problems. My greater fear would be that Americans forget what composes a corporation in the first place.
I own a small one, Pearl Publishing, Inc. My wife and I bought it from my father and mother in 2010, and Dad had begun the corporation in the early 2000s when he chose to end his proprietorship of The Tri-County News and incorporate the business. A person initiated the incorporation, and it was owned, operated and staffed by human beings.
We’re not Apple, or Citibank, or Starbucks — they are far larger and have many more considerations in their day-to-day operations. But we share something with them: each of our corporations is composed entirely of people.
Hobby Lobby is a corporation that is owned and controlled by the folks who started it as a picture frame shop in their garage in the 1970s. The people in charge have religious convictions that may or may not match yours.
Think about it. They started a business, and grew it to be an employer of better than 10,000 people. And now, they don’t want to pay for certain medical procedures that they feel violate their religious beliefs.
This same friend asked me if a CEO has the right to make a decision based upon personal religious beliefs that don’t necessarily reflect the views of everyone working for him — yet affect many of them in possibly negative ways.
The answer: Yes. It was a 5-4 split, but yes.
And, by the way, isn’t the injustice of a commanding officer dictating medical policy to everyone beneath him a good description of The Affordable Care Act itself? How is what Hobby Lobby did in response to Obamacare any different than what President Obama and Congress did to every American with the passage of ACA a few years ago?
If one of these actions is wrong, the other must be equally wrong. If one is allowable, then we must allow the other. The Hobby Lobby ruling had little to do with folks working to protect the Good Lord’s word — but the precedent it sets might be good news for First Amendment fans everywhere.
