Council tables talk on votes for out-of-town business owners

2020 In the News
MARYVILLE, Mo. — The Maryville City Council on Monday tabled a discussion of whether out-of-town property owners should be afforded special status to allow them to serve on city advisory boards, specifically business owners on the Maryville Tourism Committee.
The discussion was spurred by a request from Skidmore resident Holly Kay Cronk, who owns a business, Ferluknat Farm, in Maryville. Cronk has been vocal over the past year in her desire for business owners who do not live within city limits to be allowed to serve on advisory boards, particularly on the tourism committee.
“I think the feeling — and I can’t speak for the other gals that live outside (city limits) — but I think the general feeling is they don’t feel that there is acknowledged representation, that they’re not being heard,” she told the council during the lengthy discussion. “They don’t feel that they have a stake even though they’ve got hundreds of thousands of dollars in this town and you guys get our tax money.”
City Manager Greg McDanel said that because the makeup of all other city advisory boards are dictated by state statute, there were only three that the city could alter: the tourism committee, the airport board (which was temporarily dissolved last year), and the Maryville Public Arts Committee.
Council member John McBride agreed with Cronk that business owners in particular should have a say in city government no matter where they live. McBride, who received $1,600 in donations from out-of-town donors during his council election campaign, has voiced his support in the past several times for non-Maryville residents who live near the city to be able to vote in city elections as well.
“I would definitely be in favor of having people outside — not just within — city limits be on those boards that are up,” McBride said. “Because there’s a lot of benefit. I mean, the airport board, there are people that probably utilize the airport outside of city limits. The tourism committee, people who own businesses here that maybe don’t live within the city limits, they have a lot to gain and their voice I really feel should be heard there. Same with the public arts committee.”
Council member Rachael Martin said she disagreed.
“To your point, I know one of your things that you talked about during your campaign was that a lot of people who don’t live in Maryville want to be able to vote for who sits here,” she told McBride. “And the conflict with that is that, so do you get to vote in your city and our city? So if I own a business in Kansas City, do I get to vote there and I get to vote here? Or I have to pick one?
“And I think that’s the reason that those state statutes are in place (for the other boards) is to make it very clear that if you love here enough that you want to make decisions for here, you gotta live here. That’s how I feel about it.”
Cronk said she would like to serve on Maryville’s tourism committee, or allow another property owner who does not live in Maryville to serve on the board instead who could represent her interests.
McBride agreed that business owners should have more opportunities for representation.
“I’m not trying to indicate that the entire tourism committee should be made up of people that are just business owners,” he said. “I’m saying there should be maybe a spot allocated — or one or two spots allocated — for business owners here.”
The tourism committee already has two seats dedicated to exactly that — representatives from the Greater Maryville Chamber of Commerce and Nodaway County Economic Development, both of which represent businesses that operate outside of Maryville and businesses that operate in Maryville owned by out-of-town proprietors. They are the only seats on any city advisory board that are required to be filled by specific private interest groups.
“I also believe that the power of a vote has nothing to do with how much money someone has invested, be it in their personal property or their business property.”
— Rachael Martin,
Maryville City Council member
“So, the businesses that come into your town, pay your property taxes, pay the sales taxes, help you put the money in your bank account — they do it because they want to be part of a community,” Cronk told the council. “But, then when it comes to things that impact them, such as tourism, they have no say. Oh, I see.”
Cronk did not address why she felt that her interests in tourism matters as a business owner who lives outside city limits significantly differed from those of fellow business owners whose private residences are within city limits, nor did she provide an example of a situation where she felt her input had been discounted because of where she lives.
In fact, as of March, the tourism committee had given three grants to local tourism initiatives — two of them went to Make It Maryville, a promotional group for businesses headed by Cronk.
“You’re discounting people that really feel that they aren’t being heard,” she said. “… Yes, they don’t live here, but they didn’t have to put their money in this town, and they don’t have to continue to help it grow, either, you know? I’m not saying I’m going to be one of them, but I’ll tell you, (if) I get an offer on my building and it’s good enough? I’ll leave.”
Martin said she was strongly opposed to the idea that property ownership or wealth should grant special voting rights.
“The influence that you have as an individual does not have to be because you own a business or because you’ve invested so much money — it’s with your voice and with your hard work,” she said. “… And I also believe that the power of a vote has nothing to do with how much money someone has invested, be it in their personal property or their business property. Because if I own a tiny tent on my little piece of property in Maryville, I have one vote — the same as the mansion down the street. To me, that’s the point.
“So if we can incorporate your voice in some way, I think that is important. But I think it’s dangerous territory if we’re not careful about how we do that.”
Council member Tye Parsons said he would be against any measure that expanded decision-making for what happens within city limits to people outside of city limits.
“I find this discussion very strange,” he said toward the end of Monday’s lengthy debate. “I’ve worked in local government a long time, long before I came onto City Council. And the idea that a person who doesn’t live in a town should be able to make decisions in a town — is crazy to me. So, I’m never going to be in favor of opening up any of our city boards to external people. That doesn’t make any sense.”
Council member Dannen Merrill, who was attending the meeting virtually, did not voice an opinion on the matter. Mayor Benjamin Lipiec steered the council to tabling the discussion until a later date.
