Pearls: Dining at the table of ideas

Matt Pearl
Remember going to those potluck dinners as a kid? Everybody bringing casseroles and Jell-O salads, plopping them down on a long table, and folks filling their paper plates with the green beans touching the peachy, fluffy stuff.
Now, I’m sure you have all been to plenty of these as adults, but (and I can’t speak for the rest of you) I was a bit of a pickier eater as a kid—to such irritating children, a potluck in a minefield of disgusting food. So, I did what every red-blooded American picky eater does:
I only ate the food my mom brought.
I have thought back on those dinners many times over the years. I’m just old enough to remember the ladies in their horn-rimmed glasses walking in with THE picnic basket—that green-and-brown woven thing with the hinged wooden lid—taking off their clear rain bonnets (also good for hair control on a windy day) and setting up the meals.
I have wondered many times whether other kids did what I did, which was only to take the food that came with you to the potluck. I mean, I didn’t love everything my mom made, but at least I knew how her food was going to taste beforehand.
My adult perspective: I hope I’m never that picky kid at the potluck table again.
I mean that in the literal sense, for starters. No I am the grown-up who packs every inch of that paper plate with all sorts of things I wouldn’t eat as a kid: casseroles and potato salads and sauerkraut—foods that would make my six-year-old self cringe. Nowadays, nothing beats a good potluck, where the more I gorge myself, the better all those folks who brought the food feel about the quality of their cooking.
But in the figurative, I don’t want to approach that great table of society, the buffet to which we have all brought our hard-fought experiences, ideas and perceptions, with my nose turned upward like a spoiled child.
Sometimes, I must admit, certain of the notions other folks present to me as truth, or as having value, give me a similar reaction to what that 47-bean casserole evoked in me decades ago. Back then, I’d leave that serving spoon in the dish, frown, and move on to the pot roast my mom had set a few feet further up the table.
My expectation for myself is higher now when I encounter the unfamiliar, at first undesirable political or social notions of others. I listen. I read. I think. But most importantly, I think about what it must have felt like to that older lady who felt disappointed taking home her casserole untouched on those summer afternoons, all because picky kids like me wouldn’t try a bite or two.
Every idea isn’t a winner. When a platter full of fascism or anarchy sets on the buffet, I leave it lay. Those are dishes the human race has sampled before, after all, and the results were bitter and indigestion-inducing.
In our associations with the folks around us, we cannot help but be exposed to other people’s experiences: they tell us about the joys and sorrows, and we thus learn much about how each of them views the world.
As we continue to dine with our fellow citizens at that table of human ideas, we need to remember that, whether each individual is rich or poor, knowledgeable or ignorant, informed or misled, this race or that, everyone who brings a basket does so in the effort to contribute to the feast.
If I, in juvenile imitation of my six-year-old self, choose only to eat the food I have brought in my basket, I have missed the value (and indeed, the point) of the potluck, haven’t I?
Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany and Grant City.
