Skip to content

My Word: In defense of protest

Larry Anderson

In the decade or so leading up to armed action at Lexington, Massachusetts, in 1775, protests, demonstrations and displays of anger were common in hotbeds of dissent such as Boston. Sometimes things got out of hand.

On March 5, 1770, a crowd in Boston gathered around a lone British sentry, and the heckling began. Soon an officer arrived with reinforcements, and things went from bad to worse. A volley was fired and people died, perhaps for a cause or maybe for other reasons. The soldiers were tried and defended by John Adams, who soon became a leading patriot and went on to become the cantankerous second president of the United States.

On Dec. 16, 1773, the Sons of Liberty boarded ships in Boston harbor and tossed casks of expensive tea into the drink. They were upset over the unfair tax on the product, but there were other reasons too. They were fed up with oppression, lack of due representation, and indifference toward them on the part of the British Parliament. Their action was effective as were boycotts, publications and street-corner speeches.

Protest set the table for the founding of this country and for that reason I am tolerant of the practice. I see it as a legitimate tool for presenting a point of view as long as everyone understands there is rarely one thing going on. Protest by a concerned crowd over a disturbing issue is one thing; using circumstances to disguise a political agenda is another. Everyone must be aware.

Protest is guaranteed by the First Amendment. It states unequivocally “…the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.” Protests within that description are fine by me. Riots that may grow out of a gathering are not.

The key word in the First Amendment is “peaceably.” The key phrase is “petition the Government.” Understand colonial representatives petitioned the British government for fairness for years with limited success. At least they tried. Diplomatic failure, recalcitrance, and a growing interest in individual rights coupled with an expanding determination to establish a new country led to revolution.

If you think the American revolution was just an exercise in heroics and philosophy, I can assure you it was not. It was drawn-out bloody business in which thousands died. Many others were displaced and suffered miserably.

We have to be careful with revolution.

I am old enough to remember segregation and the protests it justifiably caused. I recall courageous black people demanding their rights and taking unspeakable abuse for the stand they took. I also remember race riots, assassinations and remarkable devastation. The innocent too often pay the price for anger through the loss of their lives or the destruction of their property and businesses.

Wanton destruction is not legitimate protest. It is criminal activity.

The death of George Floyd was as cold as anything I can recall. Those who went into the streets to protest were right to do so. That right is protected and partially explains what may appear to be reluctance on the part of authorities to break up displays that go too far.

Similar behavior in China would be crushed. We don’t want to be like China. Keep that in mind.

It is possible to abuse a right or to hide behind it.

Everyone must understand there is a reason peaceful protest can degenerate into violent and destructive mobs. Far left instigators can quickly infiltrate the ranks of protesters and turn them into something else. Violence attracts the media and the attention troublemakers crave.

Groups like Antifa are trained for incidents like what happened to George Floyd. Antifa is a nihilistic, anarchist and as far left as one can go. Their purpose is violence and destruction, and they are skilled at it. President Trump expressed concern about this group and was, of course, immediately attacked by liberals and big media.

He was right to be concerned. This organization and similar ones care little about George Floyd. Instead they use him to advance their anti-America agenda. Their behavior can quickly overshadow a quiet march. Their actions deflect and destroy.

Organizers of peaceful protests should take steps to deny Antifa access to their gatherings. They should work with police to identify those who start fires, destroy property, endanger lives, and distract from their primary concerns. To not do so lends tacit approval of Antifa’s destruction and the furthering of polarization in this country.

The left thrives on divisiveness, chaos and social disruption. Liberal politicians profit with media exposure and platitudes while little changes beyond the fatalities and loss.

Larry W. Anderson is a retired educator.

Leave a Comment