Skip to content

Pearls: Why I won’t coach high school sports anymore

Matt Pearl

It’s been about 10 years since I walked away from coaching. At the time I made the decision to stop for reasons that had nothing to do with basketball, my sport of choice, but instead were focused upon time, family and my future. In the days since, however, my decision to absent myself from coaching has been validated several times over as I have watched the high school game as it transitions to a new group of players and parents.

Warning: the things I am about to write are not composed to offend anyone. If you are offended, however, it’s pretty likely that you’re part of the problem, in which case offending you doesn’t worry me in the slightest. You have it coming.

First, I have seen us transition from a culture that respected/deferred to the opinions of coaches to one that instantly questions and doubts them. Don’t get me wrong: when I coached, I had more than one parent question my methods, but the concerted plot to undermine high school coaches by parents whose coaching experience includes a one-month season sponsoring of fifth-grade ball—well, that’s a part of the modern game that I am happy to live without.

I have also noticed a trend of parents wanting coaches to use varsity minutes to give their kids the necessary experience they will need to compete later. Wrong again, dad. Your kid needs to put in the practice time necessary to earn those varsity minutes. The coach playing your son or daughter to get them ready to play better later is absurd: what message does that send to the kids who are more talented and/or are working harder than yours?

Another is this strange, love-blinded, delusional belief that your kid is necessarily talented. There’s a general minimum of talent among all the athletes playing ball today — there are plenty of good, solid kids out there playing, but the vast majority of them do not have skills that will translate competitively into the college or professional game. In other words, if you are thinking that a coach is holding back your child from being discovered by college scouts, let me put your mind at ease: if your kid happens to be good enough to play college ball, he or she will not be fighting for varsity minutes at your local high school. Coaches love winning, and college-level talent will get them their faster than anything; if your kid is not playing, then you might rethink your perspective on your kid receiving a college athletic scholarship.

And how about when you see kids fire back at their coaches with their mouths, or with their tempers? I can tell you for a certainty that if that had ever happened with one of my players during a ballgame, then said player would have lived to regret it. As a coach, your key weapons are your whistle and your bench: I could blow the whistle and run the rebellion out of kids, and I could use the bench to remind them who controls playing time.

Was I mean? No. People who said I was mean were individuals who were undisciplined, and when I corrected their behavior, they kicked and screamed like spoiled brats tend to do.

But I wasn’t made to coach in an age when parents join their kids in rebelling against coaches who hold high standards and stand upon high expectations. I wasn’t going to win a fight if the kid’s parents were on his side, stroking their child’s ego, all while teaching him how unfair authority was when it didn’t give him exactly what he wanted.

If we had cleared the gym and put kids into the same competitive situations, the game would have been different, and in many cases, better. It’s the self-styled experts in the stands that make games tough to stomach on some nights.

Just about 10 years ago, I ended my coaching career on a low note: my team lost its Sectional State Playoff game, and that was that. Losing that last one was tough, but every season that has gone by since has reinforced my feelings on the profession: it’s not worth my time and stress anymore. Coaching can be fun when players and fans keep the right perspective. In my observations, though, they rarely do so. It’s just easier to sit and watch these days, or to take pictures in my role as a journalist; so that’s exactly what I do.

Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany and Grant City.

Leave a Comment