Skip to content

Off the Cobb: Which comes first, the jobs or the people to fill those jobs?

Off the Cobb: Which comes first, the jobs or the people to fill those jobs?

This week’s reader poll on maryvilledailyforum.com asks a question that community leaders in small towns all over the map have been trying to answer for decades: What can we do to retain our young people?

Actually, the specific question asks, “What do you feel is the biggest concern facing the Maryville community?”

The answers you can choose from are: 1. Affordable housing; 2. Availability of good jobs; 3. Availability of skilled workers; 4. Infrastructure; 5. Quality of life; and 6. Retail offerings.

So far, through just over 24 hours of voting, ‘Availability of good jobs’ has burst out of the gate and is leaving the others behind, with 44 of the 126 votes cast — 35 percent.

This brings up another question, “If good jobs come to Maryville, who is going to work those jobs?”

It’s a chicken-or-the-egg type of question.

Good jobs won’t come here if there’s not a skilled labor force.

Good people won’t come here if there aren’t good jobs.

Maryville and Nodaway County are victims of their own success … in a way.

Unemployment is virtually zero, meaning anyone who wants to work is already working.

Maybe they are underemployed, or self-employed, but they are working nonetheless.

The good news is that the ideal pool to draw from is already here — our young people.

But how do we keep them here?

Unfortunately, the answer to the question at the beginning of this column, “What can we do to retain our young people” is probably the most difficult one facing communities in rural areas all over this country.

It’s a complex and multi-faceted problem.

If you were to ask 100 Nodaway County high school students what it would take for them to stay here beyond high school and college, you might get 100 different answers.

For one thing, if we’re being completely honest, they don’t know. And honestly, I don’t know if it’s such a bad thing to let them go and experience the great big world in order to see that little bitty Maryville really isn’t such a bad place to be.

For another thing, there seems to be something that is engrained in us that makes us think we have to go somewhere else in order to get something better.

Better, I would propose, is in the eye of the beholder.

Sure, there is a greater abundance of good jobs in more populated places, but what are the trade-offs?

More traffic, longer commute times, more crime, higher cost of living, etc.

At a recent candidates forum held at the Nodaway County Courthouse during the fair, State Representative Allen Andrews touched on something that I agree, if harnessed properly, could be a game-changer for communities all over rural America.

Rural broadband internet service makes it possible to do many types of jobs and run many types of businesses from anywhere in the world.

As Andrews has discovered through his family’s Wool Shop, even businesses in the most remote places can become worldwide.

We see it with maryvilledailyforum.com. We, literally, have online subscribers and visitors to our website from all over the globe. That wasn’t possible 20 years ago.

Many of the communities in this area, including Maryville, are here because at one point in time, they had a railroad running through them.

The equivalent of the railroad today amounts to a tiny fiber running beneath the ground.

No longer do you have to be in the center of a busy city in order to be connected to the world.

That’s true for workers and it’s true for companies.

So if geographic location is no longer going to be an obstacle, what else is left?

In my opinion — and my answer to the poll question is — ‘Quality of life.’

Sure, that can mean a lot of different things, like recreation, entertainment, dining, shopping and a lot more, depending on individual interests.

I believe that the way we are going to get young people to stay here and the way we are going to get more good companies that provide good jobs to come here is to continue to make Maryville a place people and business want to locate.

We do that by improving the quality of life.

Again, that can mean a lot of things to a lot of people, but that’s what it’s going to take and I think we are on the right track to get there. Is it perfect? No and it never will be perfect, but I’m confident we’ll do the best we can.

We tend to take a lot of things for granted. If you stop and think about it, I think you’ll agree.

I just look at what has taken place in the 18 years my family has lived here.

It’s really mind-blowing all the positive change that has taken place. You don’t have to look too far.

Sure, we’ve had set-backs, but I think the good outweighs the bad.

What we have to realize is that there is so much that needs to be done that it can’t happen quickly.

But it’s encouraging to know that things are heading in the right direction and that progress is being made each day.

Phil Cobb is the owner and publisher of The Maryville Forum and The Post.

Leave a Comment