Hayward mystery solved for Oklahoma descendant

SUBMITTED PHOTO
Hayward
MARYVILLE, Mo. — Oklahoma resident Bob Schwarz visited The Nodaway County Historical Society Museum in April, seeking a link to his past regarding his ancestor and Orphan Train rider Harry I. Hayward.
Starting with a bit of information and visiting Maryville, word got out and the mystery was solved.
On May 9, The Maryville Forum heard from Schwarz that a tie has been found in Nodaway County.
“Janet Hawley from Maryville, the great grand-niece of H.B. Phelps contacted us,” said Schwarz. “She had never been able to find out anything about the orphan train child they took in.”
Hawley said she read the story in the newspaper, recognized the Phelps name, and her interest was piqued.
“I was at that railroad thing. I saw the guy stand up and talk a little bit about the Orphan Train, but until I read your article, I was like ‘Oh my gosh! I know that story,’” she said.
Hawley is related to the H.B. Phelps that Schwarz was inquiring about. Phelps was her great grandfather’s brother.
“I didn’t know him or anything about him really, but I always wondered who that Orphan Train child was,” she said.
One thing that Schwarz’s mystery had working for it, is Hawley. She is an avid researcher and genealogist. This information filled in a spot on her family tree also.
“I’d been looking for that for years,” she said. “I’ve looked and looked. I’ve looked for him, I mean I just couldn’t find anything. … The Phelps by 1900 didn’t have kids with them.”
She said it’s particularly difficult to find out information about Orphan Train riders. Because sometimes they share the last name as the family, sometimes they don’t. Sometimes they’re adopted, sometimes not.
“I’d wondered if he’d died, but there was no local burial that I could connect,” Hawley said. “By then, they (the Phelps) had moved away, I looked several times. I always just wondered what had happened to him.”
She said the stories match, but that she’ll always wonder if this is the link she’s been missing in her family tree all this time.
“I’m not going to dispute them, but as a genealogist, there’s no way I could say in stone,” Hawley said. “I’m glad it made them feel better. It’s a possibility. It fits in my time schedule. And there is that article in the paper, that he (H.B.) took an orphan child, and I can’t find another one.”
The article about the Orphan Train children she refers to was printed in the Oct. 3, 1895, edition of The Nodaway Democrat. In the paper Oct. 6, 1895, one line from another story about the children stated, “H.B. Phelps has adopted one of the New York orphan children.”
The Schwarzes thanked the Nodaway County Historical Society — Margaret, Cathy and the entire staff of volunteers and members for their time and efforts.
“Linda and I will always have a soft spot for Maryville, Nodaway County, The Maryville Forum and NCHS, in our hearts, and will return soon to visit and take place in Nodaway County Historical Society events,” he said.
According to Hawley, the Schwarzes, the Hayward Family Tree and online documents, what follows is a brief timeline of Hayward’s life.
- Henry Burgess (H.B.) Phelps was born in May 1866 in Illinois as the sixth child of John W. Phelps and Catherine Phelps. He had eight siblings, namely: James B., Lyda Ann, George W., John M., Louisa C., Mary E., Josephine, and Joseph A. The family moved to Allen County, Kansas, a couple years after his birth, then went to Nebraska for a while before ending up in Maryville by the 1880 census.
- Elizabeth Thull was born in Wisconsin in 1862, but by 1865 the family was in Maryville.
- Harry Hayward was born Jan. 7, 1884 in Brooklyn, Kings County, New York to Matthew and Frances Rozell Hayward.
- H.B. Phelps married Elizabeth Thull in 1892 in St. Joseph.
- Hayward, along with 15 other orphan children, arrived at noon on Friday, Oct. 2, 1885, in Maryville on the Orphan Train from New York City.
- L.T. (Luther Thomas) Martin took Hayward but, according to a family story, when L.T. arrived home his wife Elizabeth Bloom said, “No” and Hayward was taken back to town.
- The following Tuesday’s, Oct. 6, The Daily Paper reported, “H. B. Phelps has adopted one of the New York orphan children.”
- Hayward was not adopted by the Phelps, but we believe he lived with them for the duration of his time in Missouri. We believe he was treated well and he had some fond memories of his time in Nodaway County.
- Hayward’s mother, Frances Rozell Hayward died on Dec. 29, 1890, in Brooklyn, Kings County, New York.
- By June 1900, Hayward’s grandmother had sent for him to return the New York.
- The 1900 census for Brooklyn, N.Y. Ward 24, had Hayward (Hary I. Hayward) living in the Atlantic Avenue household of his Uncle Joseph Rozzell, wife Sarah, and sons Joseph and Edward. Also living in the household was Hayward’s grandmother, Mary E. Rozzell, age 57.
- In the 1900 census H.B. and Elizabeth Phelps were living in Raton, Colfax Co., New Mexico.
- On Oct. 13, 1903, at age 21 Hayward enlisted in the United States Coast Artillery Corps and served for 13 years.
- H.B. and Elizabeth Thull Phelps’ daughter, Helen May Phelps, was born on Aug. 12, 1904, in Denver, Colorado.
- Hayward’s father, Matthew Hayward, died on Sept. 7, 1904, of tuberculosis at the Seton Hospital, Staten Island, New York.
- Hayward and Elsie Caswell were married Aug. 25, 1906.
- Their daughter, Edith Hayward Schwarz was born Aug. 10, 1907, in Kings County, New York.
- Their daughter, Ruth Hayward was born April 19, 1910, in New York.
- Their son, Harry Irving Hayward Jr., was born September 22, 1913 and died September 06, 1916 in New York.
- The family of H.B. Phelps was living in Albuquerque, New Mexico in 1923. H.B.’s occupation was listed in a City Directory as Salesman.
- H.B. Phelps died on Feb 28, 1925. He was buried in Albuquerque, Bernalillo County, New Mexico.
