Sundry Observations: Let them wear cake, not eat it

Sundry Observations: Let them wear cake, not eat it
At Walmart, my daughter spied a blue button-up with tiny pizzas printed all over it. The shirt was part of a set, and when she opened it to find the accompanying graphic tee underneath, she recoiled.
“That’s for boys,” she said.
The T-shirt underneath featured a menacing pizza face dripping with cheese and a cheeky provocation: “You wanna pizza me?”
She looked around, realizing that indeed we were standing in the boys section, and announced this to me. My heart sank. I’ve been dreading the day she would no longer feel like she could look at something, regardless of the gender stereotypes associated with it, and feel free to like it.
She might not have liked the creepy face-melt image, but she exhibits almost as much excitement for “boy” stuff like diggers, dogs, and superheroes as “girl” stuff like ballet, princesses, pink. The promise of new Spider-man underwear motivates her for achieving a full week of nighttime dryness. I can’t find them anywhere except the boy section, which is why we were there.
I knew about many unreasonable and detrimental divisions in gendered clothing before I had children, but I didn’t know how stark it gets when it comes to food.
My interest in food messaging in clothing and gender began more than a year ago when my daughter began asking for a shirt with pizza on it. In the girls section of that store, I could find clothes featuring ice cream, lollipops, cakes, and cookies — anything sweet — but no pizza. I’ve since found several pizza shirts for girls, but the message differs. Like the one she found in Walmart last week, the boys’ shirts typically celebrate consuming large amounts of food, encourage practicing aggression or enjoying extreme sports. Girls’ shirts with food on them often display desserts as characters waiting to be eaten and enjoyed.
Since then, I have studied how the gendering of food and fashion has manipulated people into thinking that there is such a thing as “girly food” and meals more suitable for men. It might never adversely affect some, but it can be devastating to those who don’t follow the narrative written for them before they enter this world.
Fashion designers and merchandising spokespeople have told me they’re only giving the customers what they want. They have no interest in losing money and do their market testing and discuss the desires of their target demographics before accepting any designs.
Without an unbiased quantitative study, however, it’s hard to tell whether designers are reflecting something universally true, or at least prevalent in certain cultures.
My research revealed to me that the rise in mass marketing in the late 19th century and mid-century popular cookbooks influenced the associations of foods and gender that have made their way onto clothing made for babies, children, and adults.
Candy advertisements from the early days of mass-produced confections told women to be alluring, dainty, and “sweet” like bonbons, while men could gain strength and satisfaction from a candy bar. Think of the Snickers commercials threatening men that they might become “divas” if they get too hungry and those sexy Dove commercials promising overworked women a moment alone with a little indulgence. The same model created more than a century ago persists in commercials and on clothing.
That’s only one reason why women tend to feel like they have to hide or joke about liking steaks, fast food, and TV dinners. They’re told they’re supposed to like salads and cupcakes. The inverse is true, perhaps more so, for men. If a male, older than 7 and younger than 70, wants strawberry ice cream with rainbow sprinkles or gets enthusiastic about veggies, he’s going to be labeled effeminate. If he’s lucky, he’ll be “cute” or “health conscious.”
Although I believe my situation would be more difficult if I were raising a boy who wanted a pink glittery ice cream cone shirt with tulle on it, I don’t want her to be boxed in, particularly because I do fall into the gender script. I eat lots of salads, forego meat, and bake often. I laugh at her when she tells me “kale burgers taste yucky” and that she would like to have gummies instead. I make her eat the dinner, but I want her to grow up confident asking for what she wants, whether that’s a raise or another piece of pizza. They might seem unrelated, but women are constantly told to be smaller and quieter by consuming and asking for less so that their bodies won’t take up as much space, and therefore be more attractive, and that their voices won’t be as loud for fear they might take more than the portion already deemed appropriate for them.
Jennifer Ditlevson Haglund is a former news reporter for the Maryville Daily Forum, now living and writing in Ohio.
