Skip to content

View from the Country: America in danger of being the odd man out

View from the Country: America in danger of being the odd man out

International economics, in particular trade policies, is not a subject about which President Trump has a great deal of understanding; nor does he have reasonable advisors who he will listen to on the subject.

America is in danger of being the odd man out when it comes to trading within an increasingly interdependent world economy. Europe has its Union that levels the field for trade amongst its members and towards other nations. If Great Britain leaves that Union it may well become another odd man out internationally.

Asia is working towards a Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement that President Trump refused to consider joining. Uniform low tariffs and trade rules between major Asian nations (that was supposed to include America) will go forward to exclude America.

Even Africa is moving forward with an economic pact that would unite their nations in basic rules of trade.

That leaves the “new world” where President Trump is methodically, or at least consistently, gone about the business of isolating America from its quarter-century partners in NAFTA.

By threatening to pull out of NAFTA unilaterally, Trump puts in danger much of the American economy. Just the threat has led Mexico to make free trade agreements with Europe and to look to Latin American countries for agricultural goods to replace those from America.

Canada is flirting with the Trans-Pacific agreement to substitute for NAFTA.

Trade with Mexico and Canada has tripled since the institution of NAFTA. These two nations are among the top three exporters to America and are the leading importers of American products. Why endanger this?

If the U.S. pulls out of NAFTA, tariffs on goods to Canada and Mexico will rise. Some estimate a few tariffs on American goods could rise up to 150 percent. Currently, of course, there is 0 percent tariffs on goods within NAFTA.

Without NAFTA agreements the trade between the three countries would revert to World Trade Organization rules and tariff rates. All three are pledged to the WTO rules without this regional membership in NAFTA.

The three could revert to pre-NAFTA agreements, if not it could mean Mexico would charge 15 percent for wheat, 25 percent on beef, and 75 percent on chicken and potatoes. Under current laws United State tariffs average about 3.5 percent. Canada would have a WTO tariff on most goods of 4.2 percent and for beef and apparel five times that.

In short, pulling out of NATO could raise prices to American consumers and lose markets for American producers, especially in agriculture. The automotive industries are highly integrated now, exiting from NAFTA would complicate the industries in all three countries.

Companies may react to a NAFTA exit by increasing their domestic sales, as Trump argues. But they may just as likely find it cheaper to switch their manufacturing out of North America rather than risk more expenses in America.

To be sure, a NAFTA collapse might set the three countries scrambling to negotiate new deals; but who’s to say they will be better or worse. It certainly would accelerate the search by Mexico and Canada for new trade agreements with other countries and/or free trade areas in Europe, Asia, even Africa.

As for America, who would want to make long term trade deals with a nation that they cannot trust to live up to the obligations within those deals or to maintain the agreement itself?

As I said, Trump knows Diddley about international trade.

P.S. Try to support the relief effort for Puerto Rico on April 15. They still have sporadic electricity and clean water, especially in the rural areas.

Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.

Leave a Comment