Pearls: Are our current political divides really any deeper?

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
During a pleasant lunch outing Monday, I met up with a friend of mine, a former teaching colleague in the thriving metropolis of Barnard, Missouri.
I always look forward to these types of meetings: a few minutes of pleasant conversation with someone who views the world in a similar way that I see it – this fellow is another optimist about people who is pessimistic about the two dominant political parties.
We compared notes on many things: I lean a little to his right, he leans a little to my left – but we ordered the same lunch item without even consulting beforehand. We’re alike, and we’re not alike. We’re different, but we’re really not that different.
Anyway, he made mention of a growing obsession of his, which is the mass consumption of news from a variety of sources. This friend is doing what so many of us have begun to do in this time of ideological tug-of-war: we have to know where the next controversy is, so that we can read up and be ready to combat the misinformation that our political opposites will inevitably use as evidence in future discussions and Facebook posts.
We’re arming ourselves with the convenient information to battle one another over the problems facing our nation and our world.
My buddy confessed that checking headlines several times a day had become an obsession for him, and I admitted that I had taken steps in that direction as well. It’s tough when you’re a person of opinions and values (the latter of which I try to maintain through thick and thin) not to become involved in political discourse.
But I told him that I had learned to temper my curiosity for up-to-the-minute news with the slower, more thoughtful perspective that a perusal of morning headlines provides me.
Knee-jerk reactions are in our nature. They’re certainly in my nature, anyway. The issue is that we rarely get things right when we jump to an early conclusion; good thinking over the proper amount of time and consideration makes us all appear a little smarter. I don’t know about you, but I can use all the help I can get.
After my friend and I concluded our lunch and parted ways, I got to thinking more about the subjects we had discussed in our meeting. One of my post-conversation thoughts really left me with more questions than answers.
The thought was this: Are we fooling ourselves into believing that our political divisions now are somehow deeper than in the past? I’m serious about this. How do we know that our squabbles now are so much worse than in many times in the past?
We justify that by living in an age of such a large volume of available information, that we’re all more informed than folks were in the past. But are we all more informed, or can we all simply find the news or entertainment source that says our own opinions back to us?
I have begun to compare information with the bass drum at the rear of a marching band. We keep telling ourselves that with each step we take in this ongoing American parade, the drum is banging louder and louder.
What if instead actually beating louder, the drum is banging gradually more and more frequently?
What if we’re not getting a louder, clearer message – but instead, we’re getting a more hasty, droning message? I’ll never forgive Ted Turner for pioneering the 24-hour news channel: our society has paid bitterly for its growing addiction to never-ending news updates.
Now, it is the online news sources that pop up on our phones and remind us of what a terrible world this is. It’s a good thing we all tune in and join the conversation, isn’t it? Without those updates every few minutes, we might temporarily forget what a horrible place this is.
Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany, and Grant City.
