Scrapping over taxes

Scrapping over taxes
I recently published a column in this newspaper entitled “The Art of Collusion.” I described how lefties have closed ranks since Donald Trump’s election and used the tax reform battle as an example. At the time the column went to press, tax reform was in its final throes but had not yet passed.
I mentioned Missouri Senator Claire McCaskill within the column. On December 21, the Senator rebuked my article with one of her own entitled “Wealthy Score With Tax Code.” Her position was tax reform would help the wealthy while neglecting the middle class. As you likely know, the reform bill passed narrowly in the Senate without one Democrat voting for it, including Senator McCaskill.
The Senator mentioned my name in the article, so I feel compelled to defend my position, something I am always willing to do. Understand, I am conservative and middle class; Senator McCaskill is liberal by northwest Missouri standards, and it would be a stretch indeed to call her middle class economically. Therefore, we differ in how we see things. Also, her perspective is encased in Washington, D.C. politics; my opinions are formed by life in Maryville and by the information I process through weird big media and elsewhere.
I will hit on a few points stated by Senator McCaskill as room provides.
Here is a quote from early in her column: “Republican leaders in Congress…wrote a bill behind closed doors that will further complicate the tax code, keep open those loopholes, deepen the national debt, and give the vast majority of benefits to millionaires and billionaires…”
Gee whiz, Senator, that‘s about as interesting as lint.
Republican leadership took the lead on tax reform because lefties did zip during the awesome Obama years when there was ample opportunity to do so. Behind closed doors? Really? Some of us remember the slamming of the door on Republicans during the run-up of Obamacare. Remember when President Obama said Republicans could go sit at the back of the bus?
Like that. Complicate the tax code? It was already complicated. There will be fewer tax brackets, however, which seems less complicated to me.
Keep open those loopholes? Well, how did loopholes get there in the first place? Corporations don’t write tax laws; politicians and agencies do. Many loopholes are there for good reason. Senator McCaskill knows that.
Deepen the national debt? Where was the Senator during the Obama years when the national debt doubled in eight years?
Spending cuts, you know, can reduce annual deficits. I believe Trump will move hard and fast to cut heavy federal spending. He has already slashed payments to the U.N., long a financial burden on the backs of Americans. Will Senator McCaskill join in spending cuts or will she remain in lockstep with the liberal practice of not helping?
Remember when liberals labeled Republicans as the party of NO! Well…
The big liberal bugaboo about Trump’s tax reform is its cuts for the wealthy. Well, prosperous people pay the most in terms of percentage of income and in actual dollars. Shouldn’t cuts occur where they are most needed in the interest of fairness, equality and such?
Personally, I harbor no ill will for prosperous Americans. I am glad they are getting a tax break. Class warfare fails with me, Senator.
Senator McCaskill argued there is a “decent chance” taxes will go up if one happens to be in the middle class. How? Standard deductions will be raised and the tax rate reduced. Middle class people will absolutely benefit. “Decent chance” is a qualifier, not a fact.
Senator McCaskill stated I said Democrats wouldn’t meet with Republicans. What I actually said was Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi refused to attend a budget meeting with the President and Republicans, which is true.
The Senator cited a 2011 bipartisan tax proposal as an instance of Dems working for tax reform in the past. Well, proposals aren’t worth much and neither are good intentions. Proposals aren’t law.
McCaskill also mentioned Obama proposed a corporate tax reduction a year after the aforementioned. Proposals are often political in intent. Obama couldn’t have cared less about making America more competitive in the world marketplace. His effort was half-hearted at best and went nowhere.
At the end of her column, Senator McCaskill stated, “I’m going to keep my focus right where it should be-on Missouri’s middle class, working families, and small businesses.”
Well, the Senator’s statement might have credence if she had voted for tax reform instead of against it. The idea one can’t vote for the middle class on the basis wealthier people did better is bogus and cheap class warfare. Wealthy Americans aren’t the enemy.
Reform and more money in the paycheck is better than nothing, which is what we in the middle class got from Senator McCaskill’s party. As the changes roll out in a couple of months, that truth will be clarified.
Larry W. Anderson is a retired educator, author and Bearcat.
