Skip to content

Tax bill, what money can buy

Richard Fulton

Well, they’ve gone and done it. The president and the Republican congress have sold themselves to the highest bidders.

Their tax bill is 500 pages long and was presented to the full congress only an hour before they had to vote for it. This major legislation had no hearings, no open input from interests across the spectrum of opinion, no input from Democrats, but multiple meetings with representatives of large corporations.

Guess who got their interests embedded into the legislation. Multinational corporations got a 14-point drop in their tax rate; down to 21 percent. And most of the loopholes that they used for years to lower their tax burden remain.

Others who gain from the bill are the very wealthy, the commercial property industry, private K-12 schools whose patrons can use tax free savings for tuition, and members of congress themselves.

Losers include those who itemize deductions because there is now a limit of $10,000 for state and local taxes and property taxes. Also losers are folks who pay their own health insurance who will pay more because as Trump said “we essentially repealed Obamacare.”

What little tax deduction 80 percent of us get in 2018 (less than two percent) will expire in 2025 while the extravagant breaks for corporations and the very rich have no end.

President Trump and at least four dozen House and Senate members get a windfall from the real estate loophole (part of the “pass through” tax). Trump will save $15 million a year. Senator Corker is the poster boy for this break. It was put in at the last minute and low and behold Bob Corker, who pledged not to vote for the bill if it added one cent to the national debt, miraculously changed his mind once the real estate break was included at the last minute. The bill adds to the national debt at least a trillion dollars.

Trump and at least five cabinet members will save $4.5 million each, the Guardian reports, due to the doubling of the estate tax limit as will Jared Kushner (Center for American Progress).

Oh, and even though there has been a glut on the oil market, the bill allows drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. Oil company campaign contributions?

There is much more mischief in the specifics of the bill that will emerge in time.

This bill was rushed through with little ability to examine its specifics. And it is to go into effect Jan. 1. The Internal Revenue Department finds it incredible that they are to write specific rules that provide correct forms and tables for 2018, while processing the tens of millions of returns coming in for the 2017 year.

Congress has cut their budget in recent years so that they are low on people to perform all these tasks. It usually takes many months even a year or so to get ready for new legislation. For legislation of this magnitude, the IRS is completely unable to be ready for its consequences by Jan. 1. It will need at least six months, probably more.

In the meantime, tax attorneys, accountants, and corporate payroll departments are pulling out their hair wondering how they will deal with withholding, tax planning, taking advantage of the loopholes, and whatever else they do.

They have to wait for the IRS to give out the rules, graphs, and regulations needed to fulfill the law.

Conservative groups spent $70 million trying to support the bill, yet less than a third of the American people support it. What will be spent to defend it?

As for 2018, what Betty Davis said in a famous movie applies: “hold on to your hats, it’s going to be a bumpy ride.”

Today’s numbers: six million dreamers await congress action and nine million poor children without health care (many in life or death situations) await congressional action.

Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.

Leave a Comment