Getting what you pay for

Matt Pearl
I remember buying one of those plastic football helmets out of a quarter vending machine, the kind of small-item dispensers that used to set in the entryways to stores––and probably still do.
You’d get the plastic balls with a football helmet enclosed, and it would have stickers included for the side of the headgear, as well as the white mask that attached to form the faceguard.
Well, half the time the sticker would be wrinkled or torn, and sometimes the facemask wouldn’t fit onto the knobs or wouldn’t stay in place once assembled. I’d gripe about it to the familiar cry, from one parent or another, that ‘you get what you pay for.’
In our society, we get what we pay for. I’m restating the expression, so my fellow grammar police can settle their minds: I meant to end that sentence in a preposition. In our republic, we pay with our votes and taxes, and then we endure the consequences of our selections: We get what we pay for.
We elected a governor who, for whatever reasons he holds, seems fundamentally opposed to public education in its current form. He made no bones about it while he was running: Governor Greitens is a big supporter of vouchers, school choice and privatized education.
I hold no opposition to any of those things. I also hold dear the notion of providing a free, appropriate public education to every American child. It’s a major selling point for our nation’s way of life.
You never know where excellence will show itself when you broaden the base of the citizens receiving education. As a former public school educator, I witnessed the obvious phenomenon of successful kids from successful homes getting the least from public ed, and that is the talking point that the governor probably holds dearest.
But in my classroom experiences, I have seen those who come from homes where education was not necessarily a top priority––and yet in many instances, I have witnessed students coming from such origins finding their academic strengths in the public school setting.
I suppose the metaphor I would use involves gardening. When I buy seeds from the nursery, I may sow them with relative surety that they will grow into the plant pictured on the envelope. Those seeds represent the students whose homes and families have prepared them for success, and fertile ground––education––will cause them to grow into useful plants.
Now think about the envelope of seeds you find from last year, a blank envelope or hodgepodge of possibilities stuck in a box in your utility room. Will they grow? If they do germinate, will they endure their less-than-perfect circumstances? There’s only one way to find out, isn’t there? You plant them in the garden.
These are the seeds that are unpredictable, but often beneficial to help fill the garden. And once in a while, you’ll see a tall stalk of corn racing skyward in the warmth of the summer sun, or a plant filled with plump, red tomatoes, or even a colorful marigold that makes June a little brighter.
These are the kids whose futures are uncertain; public education has been the fertile ground from which these little seeds have sprung. Without education dedicated to the public good, we might never have seen so many of the rags-to-riches stories that we consider an important part of our American experience.
I understand how effective a voucher can be in allowing a student living in an impoverished urban district to choose to attend the nicer school across town. But wouldn’t we see many more examples of excellence rising from the society’s floor if we were to invest more resources in our state’s public education program? We don’t need another garden: we need to plant all of our seeds.
Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany, and Grant City.
