Skip to content

Stereotypes and the songwriters’ pain

Tom Pinney

It’s almost commonplace to hear that songwriters start from a place of grief, but that’s where my story begins as well. Viewer discretion advised, trigger warning; proceed at your own risk.

In the span of about two weeks, my family moved across the country from El Paso, Texas to Gahanna (suburban Columbus), Ohio. I had to start a new life, and I wanted it to be as closely modeled to my old life as possible, so I auditioned for the school’s top choir, joined the speech and debate team, and talked to the theater department about being involved in the shows in whatever way possible.

It helped that there were people there waiting to help me out. My first day in school, I walked into the choir room and the tenor section was waiting to have me step in and contribute. After class, two students – Trenton and Eryn – came up to me and told me that the speech team was ready to have me jump right in, leading me to Mr. Linerode’s room for fourth period speech and debate class.

Both of them were also involved in the theater department and had already gotten in Mrs. Macioce’s ear to let her know I was coming and that I was interested. While the fall show had already been cast, the set needed builders.

The Lincoln High School community was welcoming me with open arms, but when I left school, I returned to a house that didn’t feel like home, flooded with memories of what home used to be for me. I knew that I was in trouble, but I was afraid to reach out and tell anyone.

How was I supposed to feel about the fact that I had limited contact with my best friends who were now more than 2,000 miles away? How was I supposed to react to the knowledge that I may never see any of them again?

The last memory they had of me was me crying. I hated that.

On top of all of that, my girlfriend broke up with me not two weeks after I moved. I knew it was probably going to happen, but still, it just gutted me.

This is where depression first took hold of me. He came in darkness, wrapping me up in chains that made me unable and unwilling to move unless necessity called for it.

The worst part was, I was ashamed I had depression. I beat myself up for being some stereotypical teenager that was depressed about stuff.

(This was before I knew and came to terms with what depression is – a horrific lying monster that wants nothing more than to torment me. I didn’t want to confront him at this point; I thought he was me.)

It was late October, and my ex posted pictures of her Homecoming dance with a new date. Despite the fact that my new choir was far superior to my old choir, I wasn’t fulfilled. The speech and debate season hadn’t started yet (it begins in November in Ohio). And I’m sitting at home on a Wednesday night while my family is at church, listening to noise on the radio, with a bread knife in my hand.

Like I said, viewer discretion advised.

I don’t even remember the music I was listening to at that moment. It was just background noise to distract me from the fact that I felt like I was at the end of my rope, looking for a reason not to use the bread knife.

Multiple scenarios played out in my head. My little sister opening my door with excitement to tell me about her day. My mom opening my door to get me downstairs for dinner. My dad, who I knew felt guilty about taking us across the country for his job, opening my door to ask me how my day was and listen as I lie about it.

None of that fazed me. I was convinced that it was time. So I went to my desk, picked up a pen and some paper, and wrote my suicide note.

And to put the dagger in, I wrote it in a freestyle poetry format, as if I was writing a song.

In my mind, music had been why I was depressed in the first place. Music made me cry in front of my friends instead of leaving with a pleasant memory.

In addition, music had an affect on my whole family, as we were all musical in some way. This felt like exactly what I needed to do to stick it to my family for making me move not just for the 10th time in my life, but across the country.

So I wrote my suicide song, put it to some music for my own enjoyment, and after I sang it through once, I heard my family come back home. So I stashed the knife and went downstairs like everything was normal.

The funny thing was, everything was normal. After enjoying dinner with my family for the first time in months, I went to bed that night, forgetting the knife was under my bed. The next day at school, everything seemed better.

In choir, Mr. Lahman introduced a new piece for our winter concert, this beautiful harmonic version of, “The First Noel.” On the first sight-read, I felt the music in my bones again, and I was itching to sing it more.

In speech and debate, Mr. Linerode passed around the sign-up sheet for the first tournament of the season the following weekend, and I was one of the first names on the list to go.

That afternoon was the first day of build for the fall show, and I got to build a wooden box seat from start to finish. I got home, ate dinner, said my prayers, and went to sleep.

For songwriters, the stereotype tends to be true that their greatest songs come from the depths of their pain. From Adele’s, “Turning Tables,” to “Way You Love Me,” by XXI, pain has a way of bringing out one’s true feelings in their songs.

“Saying Goodbye” was meant to be my final work, but it turned into my opening act. I found there are tons of other reasons to write songs.

But more on that later.

Tom Pinney is a news reporter for the Maryville Daily Forum.

Leave a Comment