Skip to content

North Nodaway’s softball season ends after 13-inning thriller

KALEB HUFFMAN/DAILY FORUM
North Nodaway junior pitcher Keagan O’Riley prepares to make a pitch in Wednesday’s district quarterfinal game against North Andrew at Stanberry.

STANBERRY, Mo. — When the softball calendar shifts to postseason play both teams start to scratch and claw for their survival. That is exactly what happened when the North Andrew Cardinals outlasted the North Nodaway Mustangs 6-4 in 13 innings at Stanberry High School during Class 1 District 16 quarterfinal play on Wednesday.

Inclement weather pushed the original start time back over an hour. Then the Mustangs (11-10) and Cardinals (9-15) decided to play a three-hour game that featured a little bit of everything you could hope to see in a sudden-death playoff format.

Holding a 4-1 lead in the top of the seventh inning, Mustangs starting pitcher junior Keagan O’Riley needed just three more outs to push her team to the semifinals and a date with No. 1 seed host Stanberry, but the Cardinals had other plans. After losing her catcher junior MaKayla Cross to an injury in the previous inning, O’Riley had a new battery mate freshman Jadon Dobbins to pitch to in the seventh-inning.

The change seemingly affected O’Riley from the start who finished the game with 17 strikeouts and 6 walks over 13 innings pitched while allowing six runs.

“The best part of the game was that we didn’t have our starters on the field and half our team was injured right now and we had to play through those injuries,” Mustangs’ coach Kit Meiners said. “We had a girl (Dobbins) catch who hadn’t caught one-minute all-year, … she did better than I could’ve ever expected. Keagan (O’Riley) threw the best game she has thrown all season despite losing her catcher.”

Cardinals freshman Emalee Pittman started the inning with a single then designated player senior Shaylynne Carter reached on an error by Mustangs sophomore second baseman Shai Dailey. Cardinals lead-off hitter Jentry Copple made the Mustangs pay for the error with a sharply hit single that appeared to plate two runs, however Pittman didn’t touch the plate as she crossed home and was later called out making the score 4-2 with one out.

Freshman Alaina Officer, continued the Cardinals hit parade with an RBI single to right center scoring Copple trimming the Mustangs lead to 4-3. Senior MaKayla Mullett followed with a single of her own advancing Officer. No. 4 hitter Atheah Roberts added a single of her own loading the bases full of Cardinals with one out.

With the Mustangs infield drawn in hoping to cut down the tying run at the plate Cardinals senior pitcher Ariel Rutherford helped her own cause with an RBI ground out to Mustangs third baseman junior Kristin Herndon scoring Officer from third base and knotting the game at 4-4. O’Riley, stopped the Cardinals rally by retiring freshman Mercedes Todd on a ground out to Dailey.

O’Riley dominated the next couple of innings from the circle giving her team their best scoring chance in the ninth inning following singles by sophomore Kandace Damgar and junior Emma Hart, but Rutherford pushed the threat aside.

She wiggled out of a threat in the 12th inning, but the Cardinals nipped her in the 13th inning.

Consecutive hits by Carter and Copple put runners on second and third with just one out. O’Riley made a sprawling catch on a bunt attempt by Officer for the second out, but Mullett laced a two run single to centerfield scoring Carter and Copple giving the Cardinals a 6-4 lead.

Rutherford shut the door on the Mustangs with two punch outs and a ground out by the returning Cross, who was helped off the field by her coach and Cardinals catcher Copple in a great-showing of sportsmanship in the Cardinals

6-4 win in 13 innings advancing them to the district semifinals Thursday.

Rutherford finished the game with 12 strikeouts and no walks in 13 innings pitched.

“Fortunately for us, we are only losing two girls (Taylor Combs and Alisha Davison) we are going to miss those two, but we really love the game and the girls play with heart,” Meiners said. “Next season the girls will be fine because they found out that heart goes a long way. Losing Makayla, (Cross) was huge she is the heart of this team and one of the best catchers in the area.”

Leave a Comment